Captain's bed legs: checking 4x4 timber beam strength

  • Topic: Engineering 
  • Thread starter S2026
  • Start date
6 replies · 3K views · last reply
S2026
Messages
3
Reaction score
0
Homework Statement
Context: I'm trying to prove that legs for a captain's style bed are strong enough

Vertical wooden beams= 4x4 inches and 1.8m long
Timber grade = C16
load on each beam ( there are 5 identical ones) = 50kg or 490.33N, so combined max weight is 250kg
using Mmax=(w x l^2)/8, I got the max moment as 110.32Nm
then using sigma(max)= (M x c) / I, I got the max bending stress as 91.54 PSI, but this seems very low compared to its permisable bending stress of 1,600 PSI, so I think I may have done something wrong here?

Even using the total weight of 250kg, the Max moment is 551.61 Nm, so that would mean that the max stress is 457.7 PSI, but this is still relativley low compared to it's permissable rating, so I'm a bit confused here.
dont know if i should use the compression stress formula for this one, sigma=axial load/cross sectional area, but that gave me 67.5 PSI, and that did not seem sensible as its rating is 1,600, although maybe this is right?

Please can anyone help as i need to prove this for an upcoming presentation in an interview on a project I built?

If you need any more information please ask and ill try to provide it.
Thanks!
Relevant Equations
sigma(max)= (M x c) / I
Mmax=(w x l^2)/8
sigma=axial load/cross sectional area
Context: I'm trying to prove that legs for a captain's style bed are strong enough

Vertical wooden beams= 4x4 inches and 1.8m long
Timber grade = C16
load on each beam ( there are 5 identical ones) = 50kg or 490.33N, so combined max weight is 250kg
using Mmax=(w x l^2)/8, I got the max moment as 110.32Nm
then using sigma(max)= (M x c) / I, I got the max bending stress as 91.54 PSI, but this seems very low compared to its permisable bending stress of 1,600 PSI, so I think I may have done something wrong here?
dont know if i should use the compression stress formula for this one, sigma=axial load/cross sectional area, but that gave me 67.5 PSI, and that did not seem sensible as its rating is 1,600, although maybe this is right?

Even using the total weight of 250kg, the Max moment is 551.61 Nm, so that would mean that the max stress is 457.7 PSI, but this is still relativley low compared to it's permissable rating, so I'm a bit confused here.

Please can anyone help as I need to prove this for an upcoming presentation in an interview on a project i built?
Thanks!
 
Welcome to PF.

Do you have any diagrams or pictures of this bed? I'm not familiar with the term Captain's Bed, so I did a Google Images search and found beds like this:

Photo of a light oak captain's bed with a blue and grey striped duvet, six drawers across the base and an open cubby holding a basket and books.

https://www.pbteen.com/products/cleary-captains-bed/

Is that what you are asking about?
 
Hello,
Thank you!

No, not excactly! If you imagine an elevated 3/4 length bed on legs with ladders up to it; a bunk bed without the bottom bunk if you will. Attatched are some pics!
Photo of a space under a raised timber frame, with a green painted wall panel, diagonal bracing timbers and a light fitting, and a blue and white jigsaw-pattern floor mat below.
Photo of a wooden raised bed frame seen from below, with timber legs and a diagonal brace, above a floor covered in blue and white puzzle-piece mats, with a green painted wall behind.
 
Attachments
  • Photo of a low wooden frame under a raised bed, with timber posts and diagonal bracing against a green painted wall and blue and white jigsaw-pattern floor tiles.
    1000112491.webp
    19.7 KB · Views: 34
  • Photo looking up into a timber-framed bed structure with a green wall, a light fitting and a power socket, and a floor covered in blue and white jigsaw-piece patterned tiles.
    1000112492.webp
    27.1 KB · Views: 22
  • Photo of a wooden raised bed frame with a small underside space, showing a green painted wall, a light switch, and a floor covered in blue and white jigsaw-piece pattern mats.
    1000112493.webp
    19.4 KB · Views: 14
  • Photo looking up into an under-bed space of a raised wooden bed frame, with a diagonal timber brace, a green painted wall, a wall socket, and a floor covered in blue and white jigsaw-piece mats.
    1000112492.webp
    27.1 KB · Views: 19
S2026 said:
Even using the total weight of 250kg,
Holy smokes! You have a 550 pound load on top of that bunk bed? At the very least, your anti-racking bracing looks pretty inadequate to me (but I'm an EE with just a basic ME understanding who has built my fair share of furniture and cabinets that are sturdy).
 
Last edited:
berkeman said:
Holy smokes! You have a 550 pound load on top of that bunk bed? At the very least, your anti-racking bracing looks pretty inadequate to me (but I'm an EE with just a basic ME understanding who has built my fair share of furniture and cabinets that are sturdy).
No, dont worry! that's a highly exadurated maximum weight for if a few people were on there (and practically jumping!) , just to prove that its extra safe!
 
S2026 said:
Homework Statement: Context: I'm trying to prove that legs for a captain's style bed are strong enough

Vertical wooden beams= 4x4 inches and 1.8m long
Timber grade = C16
load on each beam ( there are 5 identical ones) = 50kg or 490.33N, so combined max weight is 250kg
using Mmax=(w x l^2)/8, I got the max moment as 110.32Nm
then using sigma(max)= (M x c) / I, I got the max bending stress as 91.54 PSI, but this seems very low compared to its permisable bending stress of 1,600 PSI, so I think I may have done something wrong here?

Even using the total weight of 250kg, the Max moment is 551.61 Nm, so that would mean that the max stress is 457.7 PSI, but this is still relativley low compared to it's permissable rating, so I'm a bit confused here.
dont know if i should use the compression stress formula for this one, sigma=axial load/cross sectional area, but that gave me 67.5 PSI, and that did not seem sensible as its rating is 1,600, although maybe this is right?

Please can anyone help as i need to prove this for an upcoming presentation in an interview on a project I built?

If you need any more information please ask and ill try to provide it.
Thanks!
Relevant Equations: sigma(max)= (M x c) / I
Mmax=(w x l^2)/8
sigma=axial load/cross sectional area

Context: I'm trying to prove that legs for a captain's style bed are strong enough

Vertical wooden beams= 4x4 inches and 1.8m long
Timber grade = C16
load on each beam ( there are 5 identical ones) = 50kg or 490.33N, so combined max weight is 250kg
using Mmax=(w x l^2)/8, I got the max moment as 110.32Nm
then using sigma(max)= (M x c) / I, I got the max bending stress as 91.54 PSI, but this seems very low compared to its permisable bending stress of 1,600 PSI, so I think I may have done something wrong here?
dont know if i should use the compression stress formula for this one, sigma=axial load/cross sectional area, but that gave me 67.5 PSI, and that did not seem sensible as its rating is 1,600, although maybe this is right?

What are the parameters in your equations, and what criterion are you using for failure?
 
S2026 said:
Hello,
Thank you!

No, not excactly! If you imagine an elevated 3/4 length bed on legs with ladders up to it; a bunk bed without the bottom bunk if you will. Attatched are some pics!
Welcome!
You are showing us many photos of the same corner, but we will need to see different angles, in order to provide you with an answer.

Also, it seems that you are calling beams the five 4x4 legs, for which you try to calculate maximum moment?