Exact differential equation: why multiplying by common denominator breaks exactness?

7 replies · 2K views · last reply
Destroxia
Messages
204
Reaction score
7

Homework Statement



Solve the Differential Equation:[/B]

Partial fragment of a math expression showing y/(x^2 + y^2) added to x/(x^2 + y^2) inside parentheses, with a trailing minus sign.


When I take the partial derivative of each of these equations, I do indeed get that it is exact...

However, when I do it the way my professor wants me to do it, I don't get the same result.
He told us to multiply through by the common denominator. I have tried it multiple times, and the result never comes out as exact. Multiplying by the common denominator is altering the equation and making it not exact, but that's the way he wants us to do it. Am I doing something wrong?

Homework Equations



Exact equation, integrating factor using common denominator

The Attempt at a Solution



Handwritten working on exact differential equations: M and N defined with partial derivatives, then dM/dy and dN/dx computed and compared, ending with the note 'This is exact!!!'.
 
You are right, the original equation is exact, and multiplying it with the common denominator makes it non-exact.
You can choose any path to integrate it.
 
ehild said:
You are right, the original equation is exact, and multiplying it with the common denominator makes it non-exact.
You can choose any path to integrate it.

Is there anyway I could simplify the partial derivatives, do you think? The teacher somehow got this down to having no denominator, but then he erased it. I can't see anyway to do it myself... Even if I multiply both groups in parenthesis by their own respective common denominators, instead of multiplying the entirety of it by the CD of all, it still comes out as non-exact. I've also tried using the common denominator to bring together the separate fractions, which obviously is still the correct partial derivative because I'm not altering the equation by doing so, but it doesn't make partial derivative without a denominator.
 
RyanTAsher said:
Is there anyway I could simplify the partial derivatives, do you think? The teacher somehow got this down to having no denominator, but then he erased it. I can't see anyway to do it myself... Even if I multiply both groups in parenthesis by their own respective common denominators, instead of multiplying the entirety of it by the CD of all, it still comes out as non-exact. I've also tried using the common denominator to bring together the separate fractions, which obviously is still the correct partial derivative because I'm not altering the equation by doing so, but it doesn't make partial derivative without a denominator.
Why do you want to simplify the partial derivatives?
You have a differential equation which proved to be exact as it is. The expression on the left side is total derivative of a function F(x,y).

##\left(\frac {2x}{y}-\frac{y}{x^2+y^2}\right)dx+\left(\frac{x}{x^2+y^2}-\frac{x^2}{y^2}\right)dy=dF(x,y)##

You need to find F(x,y). Integrate the equation:

##\int\left(\left(\frac {2x}{y}-\frac{y}{x^2+y^2}\right)dx+\left(\frac{x}{x^2+y^2}-\frac{x^2}{y^2}\right)dy\right)=F(x,y) + C##
 
RyanTAsher said:

Homework Statement



Solve the Differential Equation:

Partial portion of a mathematical expression: a fraction with numerator y and denominator x squared plus y squared, added to a parenthesized fraction with numerator x and denominator x squared plus y squared, followed by a minus sign.


When I take the partial derivative of each of these equations, I do indeed get that it is exact. However, when I do it the way my professor wants me to do it, I don't get the same result. He told us to multiply through by the common denominator. I have tried it multiple times, and the result never comes out as exact. Multiplying by the common denominator is altering the equation and making it not exact, but that's the way he wants us to do it. Am I doing something wrong?

Homework Equations



Exact equation, integrating factor using common denominator

The Attempt at a Solution



Handwritten check of exactness: M = z(x^2/(x^2+y^2)... partial derivatives of M and N computed, with the final line reading 'This is exact!!!' and the comparison of dM/dy and dN/dx shown.
Is there some reason you're expecting the resulting equation to be exact? It sounds like your professor doesn't want you to solve it that way.
 
ehild said:
Why do you want to simplify the partial derivatives?
You have a differential equation which proved to be exact as it is. The expression on the left side is total derivative of a function F(x,y).
You need to find F(x,y). Integrate the equation:

So I just need to integrate either M or N first, if I label them respectively as so?

vela said:
Is there some reason you're expecting the resulting equation to be exact? It sounds like your professor doesn't want you to solve it that way.

Not sure, He wrote "Exact" right next to the problem in the notes, so I guess it infers we have to solve it exactly. Unless of course, there is a more simple way to solve it, which I don't see.
 
Handwritten derivation of solving an exact differential equation, showing integrals of M and N, partial derivatives, and a final implicit solution with arctan terms.


Here is my conclusion of work to the problem, it works out with the books answer, so thank you for all your time helping me answer this questions!