Finding tensions in a four-rope system with 80N weight

3 replies · 2K views · last reply
mumu94
Messages
2
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


In the following diagram (see attachment), w=80N and the net force is 0.



The Attempt at a Solution


I basically made two free body diagrams and applied Net Force = 0 for each axis, obtaining 4 equations with 4 variables (T1,T2,T3,T4). I got T1=56N T2=98N T3=115N T4=189N

However, my answers are apparently completely different from the "correct ones", which are: T1=37N, T2=88N, T3=77N, T4=139N.

I would like to know whether my answers are correct or not.

Help is appreciated! Thanks!
 
Attachments
  • Diagram of a weight W hanging from a wall bracket by four ropes labelled T1, T2, T3 and T4; T1 is horizontal, T2 angles up to the left from the junction, T3 is horizontal from the wall, and T4 runs up and to the right to the wall, with angles of 55 degrees and 25 degrees marked.
    stst.png
    1.8 KB · Views: 538
mumu94 said:
I would like to know whether my answers are correct or not.

Either I've fat-fingered something with my calculator, or your answer for T2 (98N) is correct. I haven't checked any of the others, but they're all connected together so there isn't much point after you've found one wrong.

BTW, your method of solving the problem, although correct and the most general approach, is not the easiest. For this particular diagram, it's easier to start at the bottom and work up:
- What does T2 have to be to cancel out the vertical force from the weight?
- now that we know T2, what does T1 have to be to not have any horizontal aceleration?
- And work your way up to T3 and T4.
 
Nugatory said:
Either I've fat-fingered something with my calculator, or your answer for T2 (98N) is correct. I haven't checked any of the others, but they're all connected together so there isn't much point after you've found one wrong.

BTW, your method of solving the problem, although correct and the most general approach, is not the easiest. For this particular diagram, it's easier to start at the bottom and work up:
- What does T2 have to be to cancel out the vertical force from the weight?
- now that we know T2, what does T1 have to be to not have any horizontal aceleration?
- And work your way up to T3 and T4.
Thanks! I have another question concerning the same topic, about this problem:

(see attachment)

"If the kinetic friction coefficient between m2 and the table is 0.56, W1 = 1.5N and W2= 2.5N. What is M3 so that the system will move at a constant velocity?"

How can I know the direction of the friction force in this case, or would it have two solutions, one so that the system moves to the right, and one so that it moves to the left?
 
Attachments
  • Diagram of a pulley system: block M2 sits on a horizontal table and is connected by a rope over pulleys at each end to hanging blocks M1 on the left and M3 on the right.
    ffff.png
    1.3 KB · Views: 501
mumu94 said:
How can I know the direction of the friction force in this case, or would it have two solutions, one so that the system moves to the right, and one so that it moves to the left?

Try solving it both ways, once left moving and once right moving. See what answers you get.