Finding Thevenin resistance with dependent sources in transistor circuits

5 replies · 3K views · last reply
cuongbui1702
Messages
31
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


My teacher gave me a method to find Impedance of Thevenin and Norton. Here is her method: she removed Indepentdence source (voltage is closed, current is open) and did not put V external ( so the dependent source did not working because of no source). And she find resistance

Homework Equations


Is that method is true?

The Attempt at a Solution


I search google but nobody give that method
 
cuongbui1702 said:

Homework Statement


My teacher gave me a method to find Impedance of Thevenin and Norton. Here is her method: she removed Indepentdence source (voltage is closed, current is open) and did not put V external ( so the dependent source did not working because of no source). And she find resistance

Homework Equations


Is that method is true?

The Attempt at a Solution


I search google but nobody give that method
It may depend upon the particular circuit and how any dependent sources influence the output.

Can you post a diagram of the circuit in question?
 
My circuit is AC equivalent circuit of BJT. She said that when she calculate Output impedance = Vo/io, she put Vin = 0. I don't know what she means, maybe she removed Vin give it away or it is like Thevenin-Norton circuit it replace voltage source or current source with resistance source. In this circuit, when she analysis she did not remove Rs. And I analysis this circuit by Thevenin-Norton I remove source put source resistance, Vext and calculate output impedance. She said I'm wrong :(
 
Attachments
  • Handwritten small-signal AC equivalent circuit of a BJT amplifier with source resistance Rs, resistors R1 and Re, a dependent current source labeled beta times i_b, and output node Vo; nodes labeled B, C and E.
    11419974_670836309727585_1077887722_n.jpg
    6.7 KB · Views: 613
cuongbui1702 said:
My circuit is AC equivalent circuit of BJT. She said that when she calculate Output impedance = Vo/io, she put Vin = 0. I don't know what she means, maybe she removed Vin give it away or it is like Thevenin-Norton circuit it replace voltage source or current source with resistance source. In this circuit, when she analysis she did not remove Rs. And I analysis this circuit by Thevenin-Norton I remove source put source resistance, Vext and calculate output impedance. She said I'm wrong :(
Your circuit diagram image is very small and hard to read the labels, but even so it looks a bit odd for a BJT AC equivalent. I've never seen one with the current source feeding directly into the base! Usually it flows into the emitter. Something like this:

Small-signal transistor circuit: Vin through series resistor Rs to node B, then rπ to node E tied to ground; dependent current source βib from node C to ground with Rc, output Vo at C.

In the above circuit the emitter happens to be shown connected to ground. Usually this means that any external emitter resistor is "bypassed" by a relatively large capacitor which shunts AC signals around the emitter resistor.

Setting Vin = 0 simply means placing zero volts at Vin. This can be accomplished by hanging a 0 V voltage source there, or more simply, shorting Vin to ground. For the above circuit this would make the base current zero, since for AC the base and emitter would be at the same potential. That would turn the dependent current source into a fixed source of 0 A...

Can you show the details of your instructor's analysis and your own analysis?
 
Two common-emitter transistor circuit schematics with a handwritten analysis: the top one labelled instructor's analysis, the lower one with an added Vext source at the output, plus a Thevenin-style equivalent diagram.

Maybe My analysis is as same as with her but I know that is still exist a independent source Vin and it change to Vth (thevenin-Norton equivalent circuit), but when she wrote her analysis on blackboard, and told she give Vin = 0, I don't know she give it away or it is still there but transform to Vth like my analysis
 
Attachments
  • Two small-signal transistor circuits with handwritten notes: the top labeled 'My instructor's analysis' with Zo = Vo/Io at Vi=0 equals RC, the bottom labeled 'My analysis' with an added external voltage source Vext at the output node and Zo = Vext/Iext equals RC.
    upload_2015-6-7_14-52-12.png
    15.6 KB · Views: 624
  • Two hand-marked small-signal transistor circuit diagrams showing a Vin source with series Rs, base B, rπ, dependent current source βib, collector C, RC and output Vo, with formulas Zo = Vo/Io at Vi=0 = RC and Zo = Vext/Iext = RC, and a Thevenin equivalent with Vth and Zo.
    upload_2015-6-7_14-59-54.png
    17.6 KB · Views: 642
Last edited:
Setting Vin = 0 implies that you are determining the output impedance at the quiescent operating point. If you think about it, for small signal analysis it's really the only practical way to define the output impedance.

Alternatively, consider applying the superposition theorem. If there is some input signal Vin and and external current source on the output (you can stick a current source or a voltage source externally, but a current source makes the analysis simpler). Then the voltage at the output will depend upon contributions by both. Showing just the output circuit:

Small-signal circuit: dependent current source beta times i_b between node E and node C, resistor R_C from node C to ground, node V_o connected to an external current source I_ext.

The output impedance will be the ##ΔV_o/ΔI_{ext}## contribution, and will be independent of ##i_b##.