Force diagram of two rods hinged together

4 replies · 2K views · last reply
songoku
Messages
2,522
Reaction score
395
Homework Statement
Two identical uniform rods each of weight W are hinged together to form a structure which is resting on rough floor as shown (please see below). If the reaction forces acting on the structure by the floor are ##R_1## and ##R_2##, which of the following shows the forces acting on the structure?
Relevant Equations
Resultant torque = 0

Resultant force = 0
Picture from the question
Diagram of two uniform rods hinged together at the top, leaning against a rough floor with the lower ends resting on the surface, forming an inverted V shape.


Options:
Four labelled options A to D, each showing two rods hinged at the top forming an A-frame on a horizontal floor, with forces R1, R2 and weights W marked as arrows at different positions.


Option (B) is wrong because the both reaction forces have to be slanted since they are resultant of normal force and frictional force.

I think option (C) is wrong because taking the point where the two rods meet as point P and comparing the torque produced by both weights, the torque by the weight of right rod will be larger since the perpendicular distance is larger so there will be clockwise net torque due to bot weights only. Torque produced by both R1 and R2 are also clockwise to the net torque of the system can't be zero.

My guess would be (D) because it seems like R2 will produce bigger counter clockwise torque to balance the net torque from the weight compared to R1 in option (A)

Is there a certain way to determine the correct answer?

I also want to ask about the direction of force acting at point P
Diagram of two rods leaning against each other with ends on a floor, hinged at point P; a purple arrow labelled f points up along the upper rod and a yellow arrow labelled N points down-right from P.

There will be contact force directed bottom right and friction force directed top right. Is this correct?

Thanks
 
Attachments
  • Four labelled diagrams (A to D) of two rods hinged at the top, resting on a horizontal floor, each showing weights W and reaction forces R1 and R2 at different positions and directions.
    1632209567103.png
    38.6 KB · Views: 194
Last edited:
songoku said:
Is there a certain way to determine the correct answer?
Yes.
It's a hinge, so consider the torque balance about P for each rod separately.
 
haruspex said:
Yes.
It's a hinge, so consider the torque balance about P for each rod separately.
Ah I see, so the correct answer is certainly (D)

I just edit my post to show all the attachments in post#1. Is my diagram correct for forces acting on point P?

Thanks
 
songoku said:
I just edit my post to show all the attachments in post#1. Is my diagram correct for forces acting on point P?
Again, it's a hinge. The reaction force can be in any direction, but it does not involve friction.
To see the direction of that reaction, consider moments about the point where the rod rests on the ground.