Force of the Ladder on a Wall Torque

Click For Summary

Homework Help Overview

The discussion revolves around a physics problem involving the forces acting on a ladder leaning against a wall, specifically focusing on torque and the forces exerted by the ladder on the wall and vice versa. Participants are exploring the balance of forces and torques to determine the normal force and frictional force involved in the scenario.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory, Assumption checking, Problem interpretation

Approaches and Questions Raised

  • Participants discuss the setup of torque equations and the forces acting on the ladder, questioning the contributions of various forces to the torque balance. There is a focus on whether the torque from the ladder on the wall should be included in the calculations and how the normal force interacts with the torque balance.

Discussion Status

Participants are actively engaging with the problem, offering insights and corrections regarding the setup of torque equations. Some have suggested that a clearer sketch of the situation might aid understanding, while others have pointed out potential inaccuracies in the original poster's approach. There is a recognition of the need to clarify the roles of different forces in the torque balance.

Contextual Notes

There are indications that certain assumptions, such as the ladder being on the verge of slipping, may not hold true, which affects the relationship between the normal force and frictional force. Additionally, the original poster's calculations involve specific angles and trigonometric functions that some participants suggest may not be necessary for solving the problem.

astoll
Messages
3
Reaction score
1
Homework Statement
A 40-kg uniform ladder that is 5.0 m long is placed against a smooth wall at a height of h = 4.0 m,
as shown in the figure. The base of the ladder rests on a rough horizontal surface whose coefficient
of static friction with the ladder is 0.70. An 80-kg bucket is suspended from the top rung of the
ladder, just at the wall. What is the magnitude of the force that the ladder exerts on the wall?
Relevant Equations
sum of forces in the y direction = Fn - Fbucket - Fearth = 0
Sum of the forces in the X direction = Ff +Fladder -Fn = 0
Ff = usFn
Torque= Flsin(theta)
I've been working on this problem for a couple days now and I'm clearly missing something.
I first went ahead and solved the triangle. Hypotenuse is 5, height is 4, the last side is 3 and the angle is 53 degrees.
I went ahead and did the sum of forces in the y direction = Fn - Fbucket - Fearth = 0 to solve for Fn in the y direction and got (80)(9.8) + (40)(9.8) = Fn = 1176 N.
I then solved for force of friction given Ff = usFN or (0.7)(1176) = 823.2 N

I set the axis of rotation to where the bottom of the ladder meets the ground and set up torque equations.

The bottom of the ladder at the axis of rotation has no torque (tfriction, tFny =0).
Torque of the ladder is given at the center of mass of the ladder (392)(2.5)(sin37) = -589.78 N*m (clockwise)
Torque of the bucket is given by (784)(5)(sin37) = -2359.11 N*m (clockwise)
Torque of the normal Force in the x direction pushing off the wall is given by (FNx)(5)(sin53) = 3.99FN (counterclockwise)
Torque of the force of the ladder on the wall is (Fladder)(5)(sin127) = -3.99Fl (clockwise)

This gives me -2948.99 +3.99Fnx = 3.99Fl
-739 + FN = Fl
FN = - Fl
This will give me half of the answer I am looking for. Is my issue just that while there are equal and opposite forces pushing from the wall on the ladder and the ladder on the wall, they are not equal in torque? As in, the wall on the ladder will have a torque, but the ladder on the wall will not?

The correct answer is supposed to be 740 N. Any help on where I am going wrong would be appreciated.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Physics news on Phys.org
Hello astoll, :welcome: !
astoll said:
I'm clearly missing something.
Yes, me too: A clear sketch of the situation !
Apart from the skidding at the foot of the ladder (to be checked separately), the torque balance around that foot will give you the desired answer. No need for sines either!

astoll said:
This gives me -2948.99 +3.99Fnx = 3.99Fl
No. righthand should be a zero: you set up a balance equation for the torque on the ladder.

Tip: use symbols and only substitute numbers as the very last step.
 
Ch8Sketch.PNG
Apologizes, I couldn't figure out how to attach the image the first time. If the righthand side was zero, that would mean that there is a torque from the normal force on the ladder, but not a torque from the ladder on the wall? If this is true, I know how to complete the problem.
 
There is a force from the ladder on the wall, but it is not part of your torque balance. Only the reaction force -- the normal force from the wall on the ladder contributes a torque on the ladder.

The force from the ladder obviously is balanced somewhere (the wall does not move, we may assume), but that's not part of the system we consider.

[edit] nice picture. I had a much simpler one

1576022245808.png
 
Last edited:
astoll said:
and the angle is 53 degrees.
It is rarely of any benefit to find the angle. You are only interested in trig functions of the angle, and those can be had by the ratios of the lengths. Going via the angle reduces accuracy.
astoll said:
the sum of forces in the y direction
To what end? Taking moments about the base of the ladder, as you did, gives all you need.
astoll said:
solved for force of friction given Ff = usFN
Wrong. You are not told the ladder is about to slip, so all you know about the relationship between the normal force and the frictional force is Ff≤μsFN.
 
I figured it out! Thank you everyone! For whatever reason, when I gave this problem to my AP class yesterday we had some discrepancies on the torque and I thought I would get a second opinion. Many thanks!
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: BvU

Similar threads

  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
3K
Replies
6
Views
3K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
3K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
8K
Replies
13
Views
6K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
15K
  • · Replies 11 ·
Replies
11
Views
4K
  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
12K
  • · Replies 15 ·
Replies
15
Views
3K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
4K