Grad school-biophysics vs physics w/ biophys emphasis

  • Schools
  • Thread starter jbrussell93
  • Start date
  • Tags
    Grad Physics
In summary, the conversation discusses the differences between graduate programs in biophysics and physics with an emphasis in biophysics. The former are usually interdepartmental programs while the latter are traditional physics programs with the option to focus on biophysics research. The conversation also explores potential implications for career opportunities in academia and industry, as well as the flexibility and overlap in research areas between different departments. The speaker's advice is to choose a program based on the research interests and opportunities available rather than the departmental label.
  • #1
jbrussell93
413
38
I have been looking at graduate schools for biophysics and have found that some schools offer a PhD program for biophysics (often times in the biology or chemistry departments) and others offer a PhD in physics (physics department) with an emphasis in biophysics. I am wondering what the differences might be. Also, will this make a difference when applying for jobs in industry/academia? For example, would someone with a PhD in biophysics have an equal chance at an assistant professorship in a physics department as someone with a PhD in physics w/ emphasis? And would a PhD in physics w/ emphasis have an equal shot compared to someone with PhD in biophysics when applying to a biotech job?

Insight much appreciated!
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
The differences are what they are - the former are (usually interdepartmental) graduate programs which offer a Ph.D. in biophysics at the end, while the latter are physics Ph.D. programs where one has the option to pursue biophysics research. It seems as if you're concerned that if you do the former, you will no longer be considered a physicist - I hate to break it to you, but I did my Ph.D. in chemistry in an actual chemistry department, and work in another actual chemistry department, and I not infrequently get the "you're not an actual chemist" attitude since I work in the area of biophysics/biophysical chemistry. Scientists can be cruel. :wink:

Insofar as private sector opportunities, it all depends on what your background is and what the biotech is looking for from you. If you did single molecule studies of protein-lipid interactions, but they want a crystallographer who can start cranking out the structures from the get-go, then you are probably out of luck. It will depend on what you bring to the table, and without any additional information, it is impossible to predict.

I suppose one question to ask yourself is the following - do you envision yourself staying in biophysics after graduate school, or do you think you could end up wanting to go back to physics (in some reasonable manner)? If so, then you probably would want to go the physics Ph.D. program route. This way, you could go do a postdoc in a soft matter/materials/other reasonably related lab and go from there.
 
  • #3
That's interesting but I guess you're right... I never really thought of it like that but i would like to be viewed as a "real" physicist. So can you tell me more about how research in a "biophysics" program might compare to a physics program?
 
  • #4
jbrussell93 said:
That's interesting but I guess you're right... I never really thought of it like that but i would like to be viewed as a "real" physicist. So can you tell me more about how research in a "biophysics" program might compare to a physics program?

There aren't any hard-and-fast rules, mostly since you will frequently find that there's a great deal of flexibility built into the system. To say nothing of the fact that each university does things differently. And that the research at each university is going to depend on the faculty's research interests, and as no school has the same faculty, well, you get the picture.

For example - I have a friend who did a fellowship after graduate school with someone who managed to have a primary appointment in the chemistry department, was an adjunct in the physics department, and was involved in an interdisciplinary graduate program in biophysics. So, in principle, anyone from any of those programs could have chosen him as a dissertation supervisor. Students from other programs could have (and apparently did), after securing the necessary permissions.

One difference is, however, likely going to be reflected in the initial coursework. If you go to a physics department, you are (I would figure this is fairly invariant) going to deal with the expected assortment of classical mechanics, graduate EM, quantum, stat mech, and so on. If you end up in a biophysics program, frequently they will have a core curriculum intended to put all students on a mostly even footing in biochemistry, molecular bio, and physical methods, with room for electives.

I used to work on cytoskeleton biophysics back in the day at a cancer research institute - I know physicists who do the same sort of work, although using different methods. I suppose there might be more of a 'soft condensed matter' flavor in a physics department, but there are probably just as many physicists who have ended up as med school faculty who have brought a little of that environment over with them. I've made the following point elsewhere on this topic on these forums - there's a lot of research which doesn't squarely fit into neat disciplinary boxes. A topic you could work on in a physics department could be one where your closest competitors are a chemistry lab, a polymer science group, and a bioengineering lab.

On my present to-read list of papers related to my research, one is from a molecular biology department, another is from a chemistry department, one is from a theoretical physicist who has taken a liking to biological questions, and another is from a regular bio sci department. My general advice is to pick a program where there's an adequate number of people who do things you could see yourself doing, whether it's a typical physics department or otherwise.
 
  • #5
You have no idea how helpful that post just was. I'll keep that all in mind when the time comes to start applying. Thanks!
 

FAQ: Grad school-biophysics vs physics w/ biophys emphasis

1. What is the main difference between a graduate program in biophysics and a physics program with a biophysics emphasis?

The main difference between these two programs is the focus of the curriculum. A graduate program in biophysics will have a heavier emphasis on topics related to biological systems, such as molecular biology, biochemistry, and cellular biophysics. A physics program with a biophysics emphasis will still cover these topics, but will also have a greater focus on traditional physics topics, such as mechanics, thermodynamics, and electromagnetism.

2. Can I switch between a biophysics graduate program and a physics program with a biophysics emphasis?

It is possible to switch between these programs, but it may require additional coursework or a change in research focus. It is important to carefully consider your interests and career goals before making a decision on which program to pursue.

3. What are the career opportunities for graduates of these programs?

Graduates of both biophysics and physics programs with a biophysics emphasis have a variety of career opportunities, including research positions in academia, government, and industry. They may also pursue careers in fields such as biotechnology, pharmaceuticals, and medical devices.

4. Is a background in biology necessary for success in a physics program with a biophysics emphasis?

No, a background in biology is not necessary, but it can be helpful. Many students in these programs come from diverse academic backgrounds, including physics, engineering, chemistry, and biology. However, having a basic understanding of biology concepts and terminology can make it easier to grasp biophysics topics.

5. Are there any specific skills or prerequisites that are required for admission to these programs?

The specific requirements for admission will vary depending on the institution, but most programs will require a strong background in mathematics and physics. Some programs may also require coursework in biology, chemistry, or computer science. It is important to research the specific requirements for each program you are interested in applying to.

Similar threads

Replies
4
Views
1K
Replies
3
Views
2K
Replies
2
Views
1K
Replies
9
Views
2K
Replies
2
Views
2K
Replies
9
Views
1K
Replies
1
Views
2K
Replies
1
Views
1K
Back
Top