How Are Beam Support Reactions Calculated?

Join the discussion
Registration is free. Ask a follow-up in this thread, or start your own.
3 replies · 3K views · last reply
Guillem_dlc
Messages
188
Reaction score
17
Homework Statement
For the given loads, determine the reactions at the beam supports.
Relevant Equations
##\sum F=0, \sum M=0##
Figure:
Beam diagram with supports at B and C and ends A and D, showing a triangular 480 lb/ft load over 3 ft from A, a 600 lb/ft load over 6 ft, a 600 lb/ft uniform load over 2 ft, a point load Q, and reactions By, Bx and C.


My attempt at a solution:
Diagram of a loaded beam profile split into three areas labelled A1, A2 and A3: a triangle, a right triangle, and a rectangle sitting side by side along a horizontal line.

We know that ##Q=A_T##
We calculate ##Q##:
$$Q=\dfrac{3\cdot 480}{2}+\dfrac{600\cdot 6}{2}+600\cdot 2=3720\, \textrm{lb}$$
Then we look for the point ##\overline{x}## of the centre of gravity:
$$\overline{x_1}=1\, \textrm{ft},\quad \overline{x_2}=3+\dfrac63=5\, \textrm{ft},\quad \overline{x_3}=3+6+\dfrac22=10\, \textrm{ft}$$
$$\overline{x}=\dfrac{\sum x_iQ_i}{Q}=5,84\, \textrm{ft}$$
$$\sum Fx=\boxed{Bx=0}$$
$$\sum Fy=0=By+C-Q=0\rightarrow \boxed{By=1959,2\, \textrm{lb}}$$
$$\sum M_B=2,84Q-6C=0\rightarrow \boxed{C=1760,8\, \textrm{lb}}$$

Would this not be the case in this one? It's just that the solution tells me the following and I don't get that centre of gravity in area 2:
Official solution:
Beam diagram with a triangular load of 480 lb/ft over 3 ft on the left, a triangular load over 6 ft peaking at 600 lb/ft, and a uniform 600 lb/ft load over 2 ft on the right. Supports Bx, By and C are marked, with lengths 3 ft, 6 ft and 2 ft and 4 ft and 1 ft between load points.

We have
$$R_I=\dfrac12 (3\, \textrm{ft})(480\, \textrm{lb}/\textrm{ft})=720\, \textrm{lb}$$
$$R_{II}=\dfrac12 (6\, \textrm{ft})(600\, \textrm{lb}/\textrm{ft})=1800\, \textrm{lb}$$
$$R_{III}=(2\, \textrm{ft})(600\, \textrm{lb}/\textrm{ft})=1200\, \textrm{lb}$$
Then
$$\xrightarrow{+}\sum F_x=0:\,\, B_x=0$$
$$\sum M_B=0:\,\, (2\, \textrm{ft})(720\, \textrm{lb})-(4\, \textrm{ft})(1800\, \textrm{lb})+(6\, \textrm{ft})C_y-(7\, \textrm{ft})(1200\, \textrm{lb})=0$$
$$C_y=2360\, \textrm{lb}\qquad \mathbf{C}=2360\, \textrm{lb} \uparrow$$
or
$$\sum F_y=0:\,\, -720\, \textrm{lb}+B_y-1800\, \textrm{lb}+2360\, \textrm{lb}-1200\, \textrm{lb}=0$$
$$B_y=1360\, \textrm{lb}\qquad \mathbf{B}=1360\, \textrm{lb}\uparrow$$
 
Physics news on Phys.org
The effective loads are applied at the centroids of the areas. Check ##x_2##
 
Last edited:
The location that you have calculated for the centroid of A2 is not correct.
Much of the weight is located towards the right side of the 11-foot beam, therefore the calculated concentrated total weight should be located far from 5.84 feet from the left end.
 
Of course, I have taken it as if the triangle is rotated. It should be ##2/3##