How can I comment on or post a question about an Insight Article?

  • Thread starter GreyNoise
  • Start date
9 replies · 3K views · last reply
GreyNoise
Gold Member
Messages
32
Reaction score
6
Does anyone know how to leave comments for an Insight Article? I wanted to comment and ask a question, but I can't find a link (not obvious to me anyway). At the bottom it reads to login to leave a comment but just tells me that I'm already logged in when I click on it, and I cannot find any other links. Thnx. (I did accidently once stumble onto a page that contained fields for posting comments, but I can't remember how I got there.)
 
Where is "here" fresh_42? I tried from the page where this thread appears (is that what you meant?). It took me to the article, but I can't find a link to comments from there.
 
GreyNoise said:
Where is "here" fresh_42?
Top right on this page. The magnifying glass with the title "SEARCH" or only the magnifying glass top right if you're on a phone.
 
Screenshot of the Physics Forums Insights page header and a tutorial article titled "A Journey to The Manifold SU(2): Differentiation, Spheres, and Fiber Bundles", with the title highlighted and a red handwritten-style arrow pointing to the text labelled Ctrl + C.


Screenshot of the Physics Forums site with the search box open and the text 'A Journey to The Manifold SU(2)' typed in, showing suggestions including 'comment or post question about an Insight Article' and 'Doppler effect and frequency'; a red arrow points from the search box to the words Ctrl + V.


Screenshot of Physics Forums search results showing two Insights threads: A Journey to the Manifold SU(2) Part II and A Journey to the Manifold Part I, each with author, date, tags, reply count and forum location.
Most (if not all) Insight articles have corresponding threads on an appropriate forum. You can search them and find the thread where you can comment:

Screenshot of a Physics Forums thread page titled 'A Journey to The Manifold - Part I - Comments' showing the Insights tag, breadcrumb navigation and the first post by mentor fresh_42 dated Oct 16, 2017.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: dextercioby and Wrichik Basu
fresh_42 said:
Top right on this page. The magnifying glass with the title "SEARCH" or only the magnifying glass top right if you're on a phone.
Got it fresh_42! Thnx
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Wrichik Basu and malawi_glenn
GreyNoise said:
Does anyone know how to leave comments for an Insight Article? I wanted to comment and ask a question, but I can't find a link (not obvious to me anyway). At the bottom it reads to login to leave a comment but just tells me that I'm already logged in when I click on it, and I cannot find any other links. Thnx. (I did accidently once stumble onto a page that contained fields for posting comments, but I can't remember how I got there.)
I see this happening too. This behavior is a problem @Greg Bernhardt will need to look at. That's not what is supposed to happen.
 
vela said:
I see this happening too. This behavior is a problem @Greg Bernhardt will need to look at. That's not what is supposed to happen.
Every Insight article should have a link to the comment thread at the end. The Insights Blog is created with WordPress and this site with XenForo. The ability to comment below the Insight article directly is limited only to users who are Insight authors and whose accounts have been linked to WordPress from XenForo. In the case of those users, any comments posted in the comment thread is automatically copied to WordPress.
 
Wrichik Basu said:
Every Insight article should have a link to the comment thread at the end. The Insights Blog is created with WordPress and this site with XenForo. The ability to comment below the Insight article directly is limited only to users who are Insight authors and whose accounts have been linked to WordPress from XenForo. In the case of those users, any comments posted in the comment thread is automatically copied to WordPress.
All of this is really irrelevant. The user doesn't care how it's implemented. Being told you need to log into comment only to be told you're already logged in when you click on the link to log in isn't a good user experience.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Tom.G
So one needs to be an insight author to comment on an insight article??Seems odd. I know I also end up in the "you must sign in" loop. No one told me I was unworthy!👍