How could you see an image without photons? (imaging systems)

Join the discussion
Ask a follow-up here, or get your own question answered by working scientists, mathematicians and engineers — people, not an autocomplete.
Real named experts · corrections over time · the nuance an AI answer skips
9 replies · 4K views
Maximum7
Messages
125
Reaction score
11
What kind of imaging system could be used to see without photons? I ask because I was watching a video and the furthest we can see back is Redshift Z~1090 which is the CMB. We can’t see the universe before the first stars formed or the Big Bang itself. My first guess would be some kind of dark matter imaging system BUT there seems to be no trace of the axion so perhaps dark matter does not exist. Is there any way an advanced civilization could do this?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Maximum7 said:
What kind of imaging system could be used to see without photons? I ask because I was watching a video and the furthest we can see back is Redshift Z~1090 which is the CMB. We can’t see the universe before the first stars formed or the Big Bang itself. My first guess would be some kind of dark matter imaging system BUT there seems to be no trace of the axion so perhaps dark matter does not exist. Is there any way an advanced civilization could do this?
There can still be gravity waves from before deionization.
 
Reply
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: 256bits, BillTre and topsquark
There are imaging systems that work without photons, but they won't do what you want with respect to seeing before CMB.
Electron microscopy
Atomic force microscopes
There are probably others.

I don't think gravitational wave technology is able to form images yet.
 
Reply
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: russ_watters and topsquark
Maximum7 said:
What kind of imaging system could be used to see without photons?
What do you mean by "see"? Do you mean to record the image, or for a human to actually "see" the information? If the latter, there are ways to directly stimulate the visual cortex in the human brain; we're just not very skilled in doing that yet. And I see very detailed images when I'm dreaming, and no photons are directly involved in that... :wink:
 
Reply
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: BillTre
berkeman said:
What do you mean by "see"? Do you mean to record the image, or for a human to actually "see" the information? If the latter, there are ways to directly stimulate the visual cortex in the human brain; we're just not very skilled in doing that yet. And I see very detailed images when I'm dreaming, and no photons are directly involved in that... :wink:

Record an image
 
Maximum7 said:
Record an image
1668738756245.png

https://media-cldnry.s-nbcnews.com/...nts_9a_baby_faces_220922_1920x1080-47a34q.jpg
 
berkeman said:
And I see very detailed images when I'm dreaming, and no photons are directly involved in that...
Well, with you, Mike, it's hard to tell just WHAT might be involved. :smile:
 
Reply
  • Haha
Likes   Reactions: berkeman
Hornbein said:
There can still be gravity waves from before deionization.
And the neutrino background which happened before the CMB.
 
Any type of radiation, be it protons, electrons, neutrons, neutrinos, etc can be used to create an image if you have a way of mapping their original location at reflection/emission to their final location upon detection. Telescopes and other optical devices achieve this by focusing light using mirrors or lenses while electron microscopes do this using various methods that I won't go into. We also already have neutron imaging as well.

Just about any type of wave can be used for imaging too. Sound waves, gravitational waves, gravity waves (waves on the surface of water), etc. Again, all you need is some way to map the wave's location at various points at the target location to whatever you're using to 'image' with.
 
Reply
  • Like
  • Informative
Likes   Reactions: Lren Zvsm, Hornbein, BillTre and 2 others
Drakkith said:
Any type of radiation, be it protons, electrons, neutrons, neutrinos, etc can be used to create an image if you have a way of mapping their original location at reflection/emission to their final location upon detection. Telescopes and other optical devices achieve this by focusing light using mirrors or lenses while electron microscopes do this using various methods that I won't go into. We also already have neutron imaging as well.

Just about any type of wave can be used for imaging too. Sound waves, gravitational waves, gravity waves (waves on the surface of water), etc. Again, all you need is some way to map the wave's location at various points at the target location to whatever you're using to 'image' with.
Neutrinos? That would be a good trick!
 
Reply
  • Haha
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Lren Zvsm and Drakkith