# How Does Dimensionality Affect Phonon Polarizations?

• Kyuubi
Kyuubi
Homework Statement
Consider a crystal made up of two-dimensional layers of atoms, with rigid coupling between the layers. You may assume the motion of atoms is restricted to the plane of the layer. Calculate the phonon heat capacity in the Debye approximation, and show that the low temperature limit is proportional to ##T^2##.
Relevant Equations
In 3D,
##\sum_n{(...)} = \frac{3}{8}\int4\pi n^2dn(...)##

In 2D,
##\sum_n{(...)} = \frac{a}{4}\int2\pi ndn(...)##

What is ##a##?
When going from 3 to 2 dimensions, I am unsure about how the number of polarizations will be affected.

I know the following though:
The 1/8 factor becomes a 1/4 since we are now integrating over the positive quadrant in 2d rather than the positive octant in 3d.
The ##4\pi n^2## becomes a ##2\pi n## because we moved from spherical coordinates to just polar coordinates.

I am told that in 3D, an elastic wave has three polarizations: two transverse and one longitudinal. Do they remain unchanged in lower dimensions? My guess is that they should become 2. But if we lose a polarization every time we lower dimensions, then a photon gas in one dimension shouldn't exist, but it does since the book has a question about it :)

Kyuubi said:
Homework Statement: Consider a crystal made up of two-dimensional layers of atoms, with rigid coupling between the layers. You may assume the motion of atoms is restricted to the plane of the layer. Calculate the phonon heat capacity in the Debye approximation, and show that the low temperature limit is proportional to ##T^2##.
Relevant Equations: In 3D,
##\sum_n{(...)} = \frac{3}{8}\int4\pi n^2dn(...)##

In 2D,
##\sum_n{(...)} = \frac{a}{4}\int2\pi ndn(...)##

What is ##a##?

When going from 3 to 2 dimensions, I am unsure about how the number of polarizations will be affected.

I know the following though:
The 1/8 factor becomes a 1/4 since we are now integrating over the positive quadrant in 2d rather than the positive octant in 3d.
The ##4\pi n^2## becomes a ##2\pi n## because we moved from spherical coordinates to just polar coordinates.

I am told that in 3D, an elastic wave has three polarizations: two transverse and one longitudinal. Do they remain unchanged in lower dimensions? My guess is that they should become 2. But if we lose a polarization every time we lower dimensions, then a photon gas in one dimension shouldn't exist, but it does since the book has a question about it :)
It's been answered for me. Indeed the number of polarizations goes down. I suppose then that EM modes retain their 2 polarizations regardless of dimension (?)

## What are phonon modes?

Phonon modes are quantized vibrations of atoms in a crystal lattice. These collective excitations can be thought of as particles that carry thermal energy and contribute to heat capacity and thermal conductivity in materials.

## How does the number of dimensions affect phonon modes?

The number of dimensions in a material directly affects the types of phonon modes that can exist. In 1D systems, phonons can only propagate along a single axis, whereas in 2D and 3D systems, phonons can propagate in multiple directions, leading to more complex behavior and interactions.

## What are the different types of phonon polarizations?

Phonon modes can be categorized based on their polarization into longitudinal and transverse modes. Longitudinal modes involve atomic displacements parallel to the direction of wave propagation, while transverse modes involve displacements perpendicular to the direction of propagation. In 3D systems, there are typically two transverse modes and one longitudinal mode.

## How many phonon polarizations exist in different dimensions?

In a 1D system, there is one longitudinal and one transverse polarization. In a 2D system, there is one longitudinal mode and two transverse modes. In a 3D system, there is one longitudinal mode and two transverse modes, making a total of three polarizations.

## Why is understanding phonon polarizations important?

Understanding phonon polarizations is crucial for predicting and controlling thermal properties of materials. Phonons play a significant role in thermal conductivity, heat capacity, and other thermodynamic properties. By understanding how phonon modes behave in different dimensions, scientists can design materials with tailored thermal properties for various applications.

Replies
4
Views
1K
Replies
3
Views
1K
Replies
2
Views
1K
Replies
3
Views
4K
Replies
28
Views
847
Replies
0
Views
1K
Replies
5
Views
3K
Replies
12
Views
393
Replies
7
Views
899
Replies
3
Views
1K