Discussion Overview
The discussion revolves around the potential for observing distant galaxies and cosmic phenomena at high redshifts (Z), particularly focusing on how advancements in optical technology might extend our observational capabilities. Participants explore the limits of current telescopes and speculate on the implications for understanding the early universe, including the formation of galaxies and stars.
Discussion Character
- Exploratory
- Technical explanation
- Debate/contested
- Mathematical reasoning
Main Points Raised
- Some participants question how far back we can see with improved optics, specifically regarding galaxies at redshift Z=11.1 and beyond.
- One participant suggests that with better optics, we might observe back to the initial creation of photons.
- Another participant proposes that we could see back to the formation of the first galaxies and proto-galaxies, but emphasizes that redshift estimates are uncertain due to insufficient data.
- It is noted that the Hubble Space Telescope cannot detect the first galaxies due to their redshift being beyond its frequency range, while the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) is designed for this purpose.
- Some participants mention that the JWST is expected to detect galaxies up to redshift Z~15, but earlier galaxies may not be observable due to the absence of galaxies at that time, according to current knowledge.
- There is a discussion about the first stars potentially forming before the first galaxies, with estimates around Z~20, but these stars are considered optically undetectable at such distances.
- A participant provides a back-of-the-envelope calculation regarding the apparent brightness of early stars and the limitations of current and upcoming telescopes, indicating that even with advancements, some targets may remain out of reach.
Areas of Agreement / Disagreement
Participants express a range of views on the limits of observation with better optics, with some agreeing on the potential of the JWST while others highlight the uncertainties and limitations regarding the detection of early cosmic structures. The discussion remains unresolved regarding the exact limits of visibility and the implications of redshift estimates.
Contextual Notes
Participants acknowledge that redshift estimates are based on limited data, and there are unresolved mathematical steps in the calculations presented. The discussion also highlights the dependence on technological advancements and the definitions of observable phenomena.