How much weight do GRE scores carry in physics admissions?

[HunterR]

Hello all,
Does anyone have any experience with admissions committee decisions regarding GRE scores? How much weight (over GPA or even research experience) do they carry on the admissions decision? (Physics General and/or General test)
I have very strong feelings against the GRE's. I find it ridiculous that after earning a 3.95 GPA in Physics I have to "show" again I'm capable of "doing" physics. But that's just my opinion.
Any comments?

All the best,
HunterR

 

[Gokul43201]

In my opinion, the GRE scores are used only as criteria for elimination, and not criteria for comparison. If either of your GRE scores are terrible, you will not be accepted, but I don't think the score itself goes into some kind of a formula to determine your qualification. More important are your research experience and references/recommendations.

The reason you are taking the GRE physics test, despite having a 3.95 GPA is that the GRE is a standardized test that everyone takes and allows for a uniform asessment. If someone comes from a department that is draconian with grading, then s/he has an opportunity to prove that the GPA being low is a false indicator, by scoring high on the GRE. The opposite holds true too. If you have a fantastic GPA but do terribly on the GRE, then your GPA starts to look suspicious.

And this may only be a rumor, but I've heard that the UC schools give a little more importance to the GRE General test than most other.

 

[hhegab]

Hello HunterR,

I completely understand your frustration with the GRE scores and their role in the admissions decision. While they do carry some weight, they are not the only factor that admissions committees consider. Your GPA and research experience are also important factors in the decision-making process.

In my experience, a strong GPA in physics and a solid research background can outweigh a lower GRE score. Admissions committees are looking for well-rounded candidates who not only have a strong academic record but also have the potential to excel in their graduate studies.

That being said, it is always important to aim for a competitive GRE score to strengthen your application. But do not let the GRE scores discourage you or overshadow your other accomplishments. Admissions committees understand that standardized tests do not always accurately reflect a student's potential and abilities.

Best of luck in your admissions journey! Don't let the GRE scores bring you down. Keep highlighting your strengths and showcasing your passion for physics in your application.