How Realistic Is the Fremen Sand Attack in Dune?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Whitestar
  • Start date Start date
AI Thread Summary
In the Sci-Fi Channel's "Dune," a notable scene features the Fremen executing a surprise attack by emerging from the sand. The realism of such an attack is questioned, with opinions suggesting it is largely unrealistic and akin to cinematic tropes seen in other films, such as ninjas appearing unexpectedly. While some argue that camouflage techniques could be employed, the consensus leans towards the idea that the concept of popping up from the sand requires technology or is purely fantastical, lacking practical application in real life.
Whitestar
Messages
90
Reaction score
4
In Sci-Fi Channel's "Dune", there is a scene in which the Fremen attack Gurney Halleck and his men in a really cool fashion: They pop up from the sand and attack them.

Here is a clip of that scene:

Dune_Fremen_Attack_Tactic.gif


I would imagine that for this to work, an oxygen mask would be required, at the very least.

My question is, how realistic is this type of attack? That is, how could such an attack tactic work in real life such as popping up from the sand? Would it require the aid of some kind of technology or is this pure fantasy?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Whitestar said:
My question is, how realistic is this type of attack?
Not realistic at all. The movie is ~ from the same years when it was about ninjas popping up from everywhere: from the ground, from the woods, from thin air. It's the same.

Some camouflage might be possible, but for that you better reference the Lord of the Rings movie instead:
 
  • Like
Likes crudux_cruo
Saw Mickey 17, a sci-fi comedy, based on Mickey 7, by Edward Ashton, which I read and thoroughly, thoroughly enjoyed. I am fascinated by stories of identity and the meaning of selfness. Mickey Barnes (Robert Pattison - of 'Sparkly Vampire' infamy) is running from a loan shark and, to escape the price on his head, signs up for an off-world trip to a new colony. The only way he could get selected is as an 'Expendable' - which is exactly what it sounds like: he gets all the suicide missions...
So far I've been enjoying the show but I am curious to hear from those a little more knowledgeable of the Dune universe as my knowledge is only of the first Dune book, The 1984 movie, The Sy-fy channel Dune and Children of Dune mini series and the most recent two movies. How much material is it pulling from the Dune books (both the original Frank Herbert and the Brian Herbert books)? If so, what books could fill in some knowledge gaps?
Back
Top