How Should I Calculate Optimal Risk/Reward in Forex Trading?

  • Context: MHB 
  • Thread starter Thread starter Apple Forex
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Management Money
Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around calculating optimal risk/reward ratios in Forex trading, focusing on statistical methods and probability assessments. Participants explore how to manage risk while trading currencies, considering various scenarios and mathematical approaches to understand potential outcomes.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Mathematical reasoning
  • Debate/contested

Main Points Raised

  • One participant expresses a desire to understand the statistical calculations behind risk/reward ratios in Forex trading, specifically how to manage risk while maintaining a probability of winning trades between 30-40%.
  • Another participant suggests that the inquiry may be more about financial advice than mathematical help.
  • A participant introduces a casino analogy to illustrate the concept of risk/reward, questioning whether a 30% winning probability with a 3:1 payout would lead to long-term success.
  • Discussion includes the expected number of wins in a series of independent trials, with a participant noting that with 100 trials at a 30% success rate, one could expect to win approximately 30 times.
  • Participants discuss the calculation of the probability of losing all trades, with one asking how to approach this given the randomness of sequences.
  • Another participant mentions Bernoulli distributions and emphasizes the importance of understanding that trials are finite and independent.
  • One participant attempts to calculate the probability of losing all 100 trades, sharing their results and seeking confirmation on their methodology.
  • A later reply provides the formulas for calculating the probabilities of winning and losing all trades, indicating a mathematical approach to the problem.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express varying degrees of understanding and approaches to the problem, with some agreeing on the mathematical principles involved while others question the applicability of financial advice versus mathematical reasoning. The discussion remains unresolved regarding the optimal risk/reward ratio and the implications of different probabilities.

Contextual Notes

Participants highlight the complexity of calculating probabilities in trading scenarios, particularly in relation to random sequences and the implications of finite versus infinite trials. There is also uncertainty regarding the correct application of probability formulas in the context of Forex trading.

Apple Forex
Messages
4
Reaction score
0
Hello all!

I currently trade currencies in Forex Market, and I somewhat understand the concept of being a winner long term, but I want to actually see how the numbers can run statistically. Formulas on how it should be calculated would be nice! (I should of paid attention in my statistics class in college )

Here is the data:

I am only willing to risk 1% to 5% of my equity in my account for each trade that I make. For example, let's say I deposit 100000 US Dollars and I risk 1% (1000 USD) per trade, which sums up to be 100 trades.

I have a probability range of 30-40% of winning a trade.

The only way I see winning down in the long run, is if I can extend my risk/reward ratio.

How far can I go with my risk/reward without compromising my equity? Say for example, I am willing to risk 1 dollar to win 3 dollars on a trade, but the trade only has a 30% chance of winning at that ratio. Would it be wise to have a risk/reward at 1 dollar for 2? I know for a fact I will be a loser in the long run if I run it 1 for 1.

Considering that my percentage of having a winning trade is between 30-40%. What is my risk/reward threshold and range? What is the probability of me losing all my equity if I lose ALL my trades?What is my optimal (or sweet spot) I should wager for each trade for me to win in the long run? Depending on the trade, I can take an aggressive (5%) or conservative(1%) approach.

I can grasp the concept, but I can't seem to grasp the numbers. I would love to know how to properly calculate this! Let me know what you guys think.
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
im not quite sure how to put this but it sounds like you're really asking for financial advice rather than maths help.
 
springfan25 said:
im not quite sure how to put this but it sounds like you're really asking for financial advice rather than maths help.

Actually, it is pure mathematical. If I word the data differently, it might be able to help simplify such a confusing question.

Let's say, we go to the casino and they offer a game called coin flip. Instead of the traditional 50/50 probability, you have a 30% chance of winning and the house has the 70% edge. However, every independent event of you winning gives you 3 times of what you initially bet.

So say you come with 100 dollars and wager 1 dollar per coin flip to win 3 dollars. Would this result in you being a long term winner? Or would I have to win a wager of 1 dollar to win 4 dollars instead? Will the house stack all your money away with these payoffs? Now, I know sequence will ALWAYS be random but I'd like to know how to calculate the possible risk of losing it all. I also know that being paid even (1 to 1) money on these odds will ultimately make you a loser. But if my risk/reward changes, it would make a significant difference on risk.

However, I want to know how to properly calculate these probabilities and possible risks using the proper mathematical formulas so I can get a general idea on my risk and money management strategy. My math isn't that strong, and I'm sure there are plenty of math geniuses here. :)

Let me know what you guys think!
 
Last edited:
Apple Forex said:
Let's say, we go to the casino and they offer a game called coin flip. Instead of the traditional 50/50 probability, you have a 30% chance of winning and the house has the 70% edge. However, every independent event of you winning gives you 3 times of what you initially bet.

So say you come with 100 dollars and wager 1 dollar per coin flip to win 3 dollars. Would this result in you being a long term winner? Or would I have to win a wager of 1 dollar to win 4 dollars instead? Will the house stack all your money away with these payoffs? Now, I know sequence will ALWAYS be random but I'd like to know how to calculate the possible risk of losing it all. I also know that being paid even (1 to 1) money on these odds will ultimately make you a loser. But if my risk/reward changes, it would make a significant difference on risk.

If you have expectation of winning with a probability of 0.3 on independent trials and you have 100 tries then on average you should win 30 times. So in your example you spend \$100 to win \$90 on average.

If there is a probability of $$p$$ of success on each of $$N$$ independent trials then the expected number of successes is $$p\cdot N$$.

Is that anywhere near to a correct understanding of what you are asking?
 
Plato said:
If you have expectation of winning with a probability of 0.3 on independent trials and you have 100 tries then on average you should win 30 times. So in your example you spend \$100 to win \$90 on average.

If there is a probability of $$p$$ of success on each of $$N$$ independent trials then the expected number of successes is $$p\cdot N$$.

Is that anywhere near to a correct understanding of what you are asking?

Yes. This helped me see it quite a bit. However, when calculating the probability of losing all trades, how would one do that when sequences are random? Given an infinite amount of trials, if we were to graph winnings with the variable of time, would this have positive outcome? Meaning would we see it progressively rising as time progresses?

Thanks for the help!
 
Apple Forex said:
Yes. This helped me see it quite a bit. However, when calculating the probability of losing all trades, how would one do that when sequences are random? Given an infinite amount of trials, if we were to graph winnings with the variable of time, would this have positive outcome? Meaning would we see it progressively rising as time progresses?

I was addressing only the case you gave: we go to the casino and they offer a game called coin flip. Instead of the traditional 50/50 probability, you have a 30% chance of winning and the house has the 70% edge. However, every independent event of you winning gives you 3 times of what you initially bet..

These are known as Bernoulli distributions.
It is important to note that the number of trial is finite never infinite; the trials are independent so order does not matter; and the process in indeed random.
 
Plato said:
I was addressing only the case you gave: we go to the casino and they offer a game called coin flip. Instead of the traditional 50/50 probability, you have a 30% chance of winning and the house has the 70% edge. However, every independent event of you winning gives you 3 times of what you initially bet..

These are known as Bernoulli distributions.
It is important to note that the number of trial is finite never infinite; the trials are independent so order does not matter; and the process in indeed random.

Thanks!

Also, a few things. Although the sequences are random, I have been trying to calculate probability of losing all 100 trades.

Is it a simple calculation as this? Or am I missing something?

Does Pn = Probability of losing all 100?

When I do, I come up with 3.23 X 10-16

EDIT: n=100 and p=.7 (% of losing)
 
Hi Apple Forex, :)

Calculating the probability of winning all of the trades or losing all the trades is actually really easy (although winning all trades isn't easy haha).

Winning:
$p = 0.3$, $n=100$
$P[W=100]=0.3^{100}$

Losing:
$p=0.7$, $n=100$
$P[L=100]=0.7^{100}$
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 22 ·
Replies
22
Views
3K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
5K
  • · Replies 28 ·
Replies
28
Views
3K
  • · Replies 9 ·
Replies
9
Views
3K
Replies
3
Views
1K
  • · Replies 11 ·
Replies
11
Views
4K
  • · Replies 9 ·
Replies
9
Views
5K
  • · Replies 26 ·
Replies
26
Views
4K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
2K