Hyperbolic orbit: which focus is the orbited body at?

6 replies · 3K views · last reply
WWCY
Messages
476
Reaction score
15

Homework Statement


Diagram of two hyperbola branches with foci at f = -εa (yellow dot, left) and f = εa (blue dot, right), with vertices at -a and a on the x-axis; a line r runs from the left focus to a point on the right branch, with angle φ marked at the left focus and P shown from the right focus, with the label r - p = ±2a.


I'm rather confused as to where the orbited body is placed, and where the orbiting trajectory lies in this figure.

Is it right for me to say that if I placed say, the Earth on the left hand focus, a comet with a hyperbolic trajectory will travel a path defined by the equation ##r - P = -2a##?

Thanks in advance.

Homework Equations

The Attempt at a Solution

 
Attachments
  • Diagram of two hyperbola branches with foci at f = -εa (yellow dot, left) and f = εa (blue dot, right), with vertices at -a and a on the x-axis; a line r runs from the left focus to a point on the right branch, with angle φ marked at the left focus and P shown from the right focus, with the label r - p = ±2a.
    Screen Shot 2017-11-26 at 3.46.21 AM.png
    8.4 KB · Views: 1,270
WWCY said:

Homework Statement


View attachment 215615

I'm rather confused as to where the orbited body is placed, and where the orbiting trajectory lies in this figure.

Is it right for me to say that if I placed say, the Earth on the left hand focus, a comet with a hyperbolic trajectory will travel a path defined by the equation ##r - P = -2a##?

Thanks in advance.

Homework Equations

The Attempt at a Solution

Looks right.
 
haruspex said:
Looks right.

Hi, thanks for clearing that up!

Edit: Is r-P = 2a also a valid hyperbolic orbit?
 
WWCY said:
Hi, thanks for clearing that up!

Edit: Is r-P = 2a also a valid hyperbolic orbit?
Not if the sun is at the negative focus.
 
haruspex said:
Not if the sun is at the negative focus.

But if I do want to use r - P = 2a, and place my planet on the right hand focus, wouldn't I need to redefine r to originate from the right focus and P from the left? This gives r - P = -2a again.

Thank you
 
WWCY said:
But if I do want to use r - P = 2a, and place my planet on the right hand focus, wouldn't I need to redefine r to originate from the right focus and P from the left? This gives r - P = -2a again.

Thank you
It depends how you are defining r and P.
If you define r as distance from the left focus and P that from the right focus then for the gravitational source at the left focus it is r-P=-2a; for the gravitational source at the right focus it's r-P=2a.
But if you define r as distance from gravitational source and P as distance from the other focus then it is r-P=-2a whichever side the source is.
 
haruspex said:
It depends how you are defining r and P.
If you define r as distance from the left focus and P that from the right focus then for the gravitational source at the left focus it is r-P=-2a; for the gravitational source at the right focus it's r-P=2a.
But if you define r as distance from gravitational source and P as distance from the other focus then it is r-P=-2a whichever side the source is.

Thanks!