Indicating the onset of instability on a graph

3 replies · 2K views · last reply
Pietair
Messages
57
Reaction score
0
Good day,

Homework Statement


Indicate on the graph the onset of instability.

The graph:

Plots of a closed-loop step response: the top graph shows output c(t) in red against a green step input versus time, and the bottom graph shows control signal u(t) versus time, with Kp 1.5, Ki 0 and Kd 0 printed below.


I really have no idea how I can indicate the onset of instability on such a graph.

Thanks in advance!
 
It isn't, that's the reason I really don't know how to indicate the onset of instability on that graph...
 
Well then there's your answer... If it's not unstable, how can you indicate the point where it becomes unstable?