Interest calculated daily compounded monthly

  • Context: Undergrad 
  • Thread starter Thread starter bradles
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Interest
Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around calculating the time required to pay off a loan with daily interest accrual but monthly compounding, while making fortnightly repayments. Participants explore various methods and formulas to model this financial scenario, incorporating complexities such as changing principal amounts and the timing of repayments.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Mathematical reasoning
  • Debate/contested

Main Points Raised

  • One participant proposes a formula involving daily interest calculations and fortnightly repayments, detailing the accrued interest over specific periods.
  • Another participant questions the necessity of daily calculations if interest is compounded monthly, suggesting a simpler monthly interest calculation instead.
  • A participant explains the process of interest accrual over 14-day periods, providing a detailed breakdown of how the loan balance changes with each payment and interest accumulation.
  • There is a suggestion to calculate the average daily balance to determine the principal for monthly interest calculations, referencing practices used by credit card companies.
  • Another participant acknowledges the complexity of the situation and expresses uncertainty about developing a formula, indicating a preference for spreadsheet simulations despite their computational demands.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express differing views on the necessity and methodology of calculating daily interest versus monthly compounding. There is no consensus on a single approach or formula, and the discussion remains unresolved regarding the best method to model the loan repayment scenario.

Contextual Notes

Participants highlight the complexity of the loan repayment structure, including the impact of changing principal amounts and the timing of repayments on interest calculations. There are also considerations regarding the approximation of monthly interest due to the non-standard month length.

bradles
Messages
6
Reaction score
0
Does anyone know how I can work out a formula to calculate how long it will take to pay a loan back to zero if the interest is on a loan is calculated daily but compounded at the end of the month. To add another level of complexity, assume you are making fortnightly repayments.

P (Principal) = $500,000
E (Fortnightly Repayments) = $2,500
r (annual interest rate) = 8.59%
t (daily compound interest rate) = \frac {0.0859}{365}

I started out with the following:

A_0 = P

A_1_4 = P-E

A_2_8 = P-2E

A_3_0 = A_2_8 + 14(A_0 * t) + 14(A_1_4 * t) + 2(A_2_8 * t)

= P - 2E + 14(Pt) + 14(Pt-Et) + 2(Pt-2Et)

= P-2E+30Pt-18Et



and continuing...

A_4_2 = A_3_0 - E = P-3E+30Pt-18Et

A_5_6 = A_4_2 - E = P-4E+30Pt-18Et

A_6_0 = A_5_6 + 12(A_3_0 * t) + 14(A_4_2 * t) + 4(A_5_6 * t)


A_1_4 and A_2_8 is where I make repayments. A_3_0 is where the interest is finally compounded.

Am I heading in the right direction for this?

Can anyone enlighten me on the best way to go about solving this?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
bradles said:
Does anyone know how I can work out a formula to calculate how long it will take to pay a loan back to zero if the interest is on a loan is calculated daily but compounded at the end of the month. To add another level of complexity, assume you are making fortnightly repayments.

P (Principal) = $500,000
E (Fortnightly Repayments) = $2,500
r (annual interest rate) = 8.59%
t (daily compound interest rate) = \frac {0.0859}{365}
There is no reason to "calculate the interest daily" if you don't do anything with it! If the interest is being compounded monthly, then calculate it monthly: monthly interest is 0.0859/12= 0.00716.

I started out with the following:

A_0 = P

A_1_4 = P-E

A_2_8 = P-2E

A_3_0 = A_2_8 + 14(A_0 * t) + 14(A_1_4 * t) + 2(A_2_8 * t)

= P - 2E + 14(Pt) + 14(Pt-Et) + 2(Pt-2Et)

= P-2E+30Pt-18Et



and continuing...

A_4_2 = A_3_0 - E = P-3E+30Pt-18Et

A_5_6 = A_4_2 - E = P-4E+30Pt-18Et

A_6_0 = A_5_6 + 12(A_3_0 * t) + 14(A_4_2 * t) + 4(A_5_6 * t)


A_1_4 and A_2_8 is where I make repayments. A_3_0 is where the interest is finally compounded.

Am I heading in the right direction for this?

Can anyone enlighten me on the best way to go about solving this?[/QUOTE]
I'm not sure I understand this. The interest is compounded monthly but how often are you paying on the loan?
 
Let me explain. I will change from a straight 30 days being one month though...just to make things more complicated...sorry.

You start out with a loan of $500,000. Each day 8.59%/365 * $500,000 accrues in interest for 14 days until you make a payment of $2,500.

So the balance at day 14 is $500,000 - $2,500 = $497,500 (with $1647.39 in interest accrued so far).

For the next 14 days the loan accrues 8.59%/365 * $497,500 in interest. When you make a payment on day 28 the balance is $497,500 - $2,500 = $495,000 (with $1,639.16 interest accruing on the $497,500 for those 14 days).

Lets say that day also happened to be the compound date (the day the interest is actually charged and capitilised into the loan. The balance would be:

$495,000
+ $1,647.39 (interest accrued in the first 14 days)
+ $1,639.16 (interest accrued in the second 14 days)
------------------
$498,286.55

Then the cycle continues.

Banks here calculate interest daily and charge it to the loan on the 28th of each month. You can choose to make repayments monthly, fortnightly or weekly, however interest is still accrued daily and charged on the 28th of each month.

I was wondering if there is a way you could calculate things like what your repayments would need to be to pay off a loan of this type in "x" years. Or to work out how long it would take you to pay off a loan of "x" amount repaying "y" every fortnight. etc.

Hope that makes sense.

Brad
 
Calculate the average daily balance. And use that as your principal for each month. Most credit card companies calculate interest this way.
 
Now I see why you want to calculate the interest daily- the principle changes in the middle of the month.
But you can still do it "monthly". Since for half the month you owe $500000 and for half the month $497500 so for the entire month you owe an "average" of (500000+ 497500)/2= $498750. Calculating $498750*0.0859/12 will give you approximately what you have. "Approximately" because 28 days is not exactly one month.
 
I'd like to try and develop a formula for it...but I'm not sure it's possible. I can simulate it on a spreadsheet but it requires a lot of data and it gets slow in the calculations.

I thought I could develop a formula to save all the number crunching.
 

Similar threads

Replies
2
Views
11K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
11K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
4K