Discussion Overview
The discussion revolves around the legality and safety of packing deuterium oxide (D2O) in checked luggage for a flight on American Airlines from Phoenix to Albuquerque. Participants explore various aspects including regulations, potential hazards, and practical experiences related to transporting D2O.
Discussion Character
- Debate/contested
- Exploratory
- Technical explanation
Main Points Raised
- Some participants suggest that packing a liter of D2O should not pose any legal issues, citing its non-hazardous nature compared to other common items like laptops.
- Others express caution, recommending that the airline be contacted directly for confirmation, as the final decision rests with them.
- Concerns are raised about the temperature in the cargo hold potentially causing the D2O to freeze, which could lead to a bottle bursting.
- One participant mentions that D2O is not classified as dangerous goods by IATA or the Department of Transportation, implying it should be permissible.
- Another participant shares their experience of successfully transporting liquids in checked baggage, suggesting that D2O, which resembles water, would likely go unnoticed.
- Some participants discuss the importance of labeling the bottle clearly as 'NON TOXIC' to avoid complications during security checks.
- There are humorous exchanges regarding the potential for misunderstandings with TSA agents about the nature of D2O.
- Participants also touch on the TSA's regulations regarding liquids, noting that containers over 100ml are not allowed in the cabin but may be permitted in checked baggage at the captain's discretion.
- One participant mentions receiving a response from AskTSA indicating that checking D2O should be fine.
Areas of Agreement / Disagreement
Participants do not reach a consensus on the best approach to take regarding the transport of D2O. While some feel confident about its legality, others emphasize the need for caution and direct communication with the airline or TSA.
Contextual Notes
Participants express uncertainty about the effects of temperature on D2O during transport and the potential for it to be flagged during security checks. There are also references to the broader context of TSA regulations regarding other substances, such as marijuana, which are mentioned in a tangential manner.