Dale
Mentor
- 36,404
- 15,113
There are a number of issues with that approach. @Ibix mentioned that it doesn’t explain the reciprocal nature of time dilation.jkourany said:So it seems speed is affecting matter not time.
Another problem is that it requires a lot of unexplained coincidence. If it isn’t time then why does EM’s effect dilate the same as the strong force and the weak force and gravity?
But in my mind the biggest problem is that it is scientifically meaningless. If you cannot propose a specific experiment whose measured outcome would depend on the difference between “speed is affecting matter not time” vs “speed is affecting time” then nature doesn’t care about the difference between the two. If there is no possible experimental difference then the distinction is all in your mind and doesn’t describe anything about the universe.