Jupiter appearing flashy - red on top, blue bottom

  • Context: Undergrad 
  • Thread starter Thread starter bahamagreen
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Jupiter
Join the discussion
Ask a follow-up here, or get your own question answered by working scientists, mathematicians and engineers — people, not an autocomplete.
Real named experts · corrections over time · the nuance an AI answer skips
Sign up Log in
49 replies · 8K views
bahamagreen
Messages
1,015
Reaction score
52
TL;DR
Been noticing something in night sky flashy with red and blue. Identified as Jupiter; any explanation for the flashy colors?
Jupiter.jpg


Been noticing this for a few evenings; didn't know it was Jupiter until this evening using https://stellarium-web.org/ (image from this evening).
Has been distinctly flashy more than other objects with a slight red flash at the top and a blue flash close to the bottom. Last night I looked with binoculars and confirmed the flashiness and the colors.
Stellarium indicates four moons are near or within the subtended angle of Jupiter's disc. Wonder if position(s) of Jupiter's moon(s) might be the cause - refraction? diffraction? dispersion? lateral chromatic aberration (from the source)?
 
Astronomy news on Phys.org
bahamagreen said:
Wonder if position(s) of Jupiter's moon(s) might be the cause
I doubt it. I don't think their brightness and angular separation from Jupiter are large enough to cause this.

bahamagreen said:
Has been distinctly flashy more than other objects with a slight red flash at the top and a blue flash close to the bottom.
Planets don't typically experience this sort of optical phenomenon, as they have a much larger angular diameter than stars do, so I'm not sure what could be causing it. Perhaps an exceptionally turbulent atmosphere?
 
Reply
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: davenn
anorlunda said:
Might you be seeing aurora on Jupiter?
With the naked eye? I find that extremely unlikely. I think you'd be hard pressed to see an aurora on Jupiter even through a telescope. Probably comparable to trying to see an aurora here on Earth during the daytime.
 
Reply
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Motore
I just looked now, naked eye and binoculars.
With naked eye there is a red dot at the top of the disc that appears and disappears every few seconds with a general flashiness near the bottom of the disc.
With binoculars, the general flashiness looks more green than blue, the red dot is easy to see.
May I ask that people take a look, naked eye and with equipment, to at least confirm and maybe better describe what is seen?
 
bahamagreen said:
I just looked now, naked eye and binoculars.
With naked eye there is a red dot at the top of the disc that appears and disappears every few seconds with a general flashiness near the bottom of the disc.
With binoculars, the general flashiness looks more green than blue, the red dot is easy to see.
May I ask that people take a look, naked eye and with equipment, to at least confirm and maybe better describe what is seen?

You really sure it's Jupiter ?
Planets don't scintillate but stars do

where in the world are you and what direction are you looking
and I will see if I can spot it on my astronomy program
 
That is why I am asking... Jupiter is much more flashy than any other objects. The colors are particularly of interest.
I am in Houston. Early posts were from early evening looking SSW. The last post was from pre-dawn looking NNW.
Spotting it on a program to confirm it's Jupiter would be good. Take a look when you get a chance to describe the color features, please.
 
bahamagreen said:
That is why I am asking... Jupiter is much more flashy than any other objects. The colors are particularly of interest.
I am in Houston. Early posts were from early evening looking SSW. The last post was from pre-dawn looking NNW.
Spotting it on a program to confirm it's Jupiter would be good. Take a look when you get a chance to describe the color features, please.
If your directions are correct, then that cannot be Jupiter. Jupiter is in the southwest in the early morning and the southeast in the early evening.
 
Reply
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: davenn and sophiecentaur
Stellarium right now, my local time 11:21 AM with the Sun up in the sky (I just checked) is indicating the time is 21:12 PM and showing the Sun under the horizon... with the location indicated "near Houston".
So yes, likely not Jupiter. Thanks everyone so far, would like to figure out what it is.
 
I would bet money that what the OP is seeing is the planetary equivalent of scintillation (twinkling).

Planets are not immune to atmospheric distortion; it's just that they will jiggle in place, rather than point-to-point.

And the red/blue makes sense too, when you consider the differing refractivity of red and blue light.

I'll bet even more that, were one to train a scope on ol' Jupe, you would still see it jumping up and down, flashing red and blue.

1629046725649.png
 
Last edited:
Reply
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: russ_watters
Looks like Stellarium finds my location automatically but does not use that to fix the time. I just corrected the time and reloaded the web page... the time reverted back to 21:05 PM and showed a night sky.
I will correct the time to sidereal time this evening and see if I can correctly identify the object.
 
Vanadium 50 said:
How much?
And real money or loonies?
Real Canadian money of course!
1629047140843.png
 
Reply
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Keith_McClary
After determining sidereal time, I realize Stellarium is automatically showing correct sidereal time for my location, but is still showing a night sky with the Sun under the horizon.
May have to find a different sky application.
 
bahamagreen said:
May have to find a different sky application.

there's nothing wrong with Stellarium is you have time and location set properly
 
Reply
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: George Jones, Vanadium 50 and russ_watters
DaveC426913 said:
I would bet money that what the OP is seeing is the planetary equivalent of scintillation (twinkling).

Planets are not immune to atmospheric distortion; it's just that they will jiggle in place, rather than point-to-point.

And the red/blue makes sense too, when you consider the differing refractivity of red and blue light.

I'll bet even more that, were one to train a scope on ol' Jupe, you would still see it jumping up and down, flashing red and blue.

View attachment 287572
This is absolutely the right answer: Refraction plus scintillation on a bright object that is low to the sky.
 
Vanadium 50 said:
Or two different bright objects.
...something something multiplying entities unnecessarily.. something...:wink:
 
Reply
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: sophiecentaur and russ_watters
Vanadium 50 said:
Or two different bright objects.

[separate post]

Nonsense. Jupiter was not where he claimed it to be. See upthread.
That's not an answer to the OP's question. The OP wasn't asking what object he was looking at, he was asking why it was flashing red and blue.
 
Vanadium 50 said:
Nonsense. Jupiter was not where he claimed it to be. See upthread.
1. I checked upthread before posting. I may be wrong but, as far as I can tell, he hasn't gotten a definitive answer from his software, so the jury is still out on that.

2. I am perfectly happy with it being any other planetary body.
 
Last edited:
Reply
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: russ_watters
Stellarium is figured out, works properly.
Start with the Moon and there are four stars leading out to the left... the flashy object is the third one: Antares.
Please have a look.
 
Reply
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Drakkith
Google is happy to report you are not the first to ask this question, so you probably identified it right this time

https://www.cloudynights.com/topic/547826-antares-particular-blinking-apearance/

DaveC426913 said:
I am perfectly happy with it being any other planetary body.
The only things you knew at this point are that it blinks and it's not Jupiter. I don't feel like the evidence pointed towards it being a planet...
 
Office_Shredder said:
Google is happy to report you are not the first to ask this question, so you probably identified it right this time

https://www.cloudynights.com/topic/547826-antares-particular-blinking-apearance/

The only things you knew at this point are that it blinks and it's not Jupiter. I don't feel like the evidence pointed towards it being a planet...
With a reminder of what the OP's question was (it was not "what object did I see?"), the answer from cloudynights is the same as the answer given by @DaveC426913 in post #15.

Also, this 'planet or star?' debate is a red herring because the popular belief that planets don't twinkle because they aren't point sources isn't quite correct unless "twinkling" is narrowly defined to exclude objects above a certain size (atmospheric seeing size).
 
Reply
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: DaveC426913
This is the effect to which I was referring.

http://www.ianmorison.com/combating-atmospheric-dispersion/

"It appears as a vertical spectrum. As blue light is preferentially scattered in the atmosphere, the blue end is less bright. This is an extreme result of atmospheric dispersion – the atmosphere acting as a prism."

1629148952167.png

Combine this with scintillation, and you have a point of light that switches between red and blue.

Granted, the above is Mercury, but the effect applies to stars too, especially ones with a non-point disc.

OP: how high in the sky was it? The effect is more pronounced the lower in the sky it is.
 
Reply
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: russ_watters