suppose that [tex]\{ v_1,v_2,v_3\}[/tex] is a set of dependent vectors. Prove that [tex] \{v_1,(v_1+v_2),v_3\}[/tex] is also a set of dependent vectors?(adsbygoogle = window.adsbygoogle || []).push({});

Ok, I have two ways of going about it. My concern is about the first one, it looks like it is not correct the way i did it, i think so, cuz i managed to find some kind of counter example, but i cannot see why it doesn't hold,because it looks logical to me.

Method 1.

Since [tex]\{ v_1,v_2,v_3\}[/tex] lin. dependent set, we know that the vector equation:

[tex]av_1+bv_2+cv_3=0[/tex] has a non trivial solution, that is at least one of a,b,c is a non-zero scalar. Now, let's take a linear combination of the vectors [tex] \{v_1,(v_1+v_2),v_3\}[/tex]

[tex] av_1+b(v_1+v_2)+cv_3=0[/tex] my goal is to show that this eq. has a nontrivial sol. that is that one of, a,b,c must be nonzero. So:

[tex] av_1+b(v_1+v_2)+cv_3=0=>av_1+bv_1+bv_2+cv_3=0=>(av_1+bv_2+cv_3)+bv_1=0=>0+bv_1=0[/tex] SO, i concluded then that [tex]v_1=0, or, b=0[/tex] Then if [tex] v_1=0[/tex] we know that every set that contains the zero vector is dependent, so i concluded that the set [tex] \{v_1,(v_1+v_2),v_3\}[/tex] is also dependent. On the other hand, if b=0, then either a, or c must be different from zero, so again this set is lin. dependent.

I am not convinced that this works because of this:

Let[tex]v_1=[1,2,3]^T,v_2=[2,-1,4]^T,v_3=[0,5,2]^T[/tex] then none of these vectors is zero, and they are also lin. dependent. so if i try to follow the same logic as above, in here to show that the set [tex] \{v_1,(v_1+v_2),v_3\}[/tex] is lin. dependent i end up with a contradiction:

[tex] bv_2=0[/tex] but, b is not necessarly zero. SO, where have i gone wrong? I mean why the above doesn't work?

Here is the second method that i used to prove that, this is way shorter, I again took a lin. comb on the vectors in the set:[tex] \{v_1,(v_1+v_2),v_3\}[/tex]

THat is:[tex] av_1+b(v_1+v_2)+cv_3=0[/tex] then after a little manipulation we have:

[tex] (a+b)v_1+bv_2+cv_3=0[/tex] now since [tex]v_1,v_2,v_3[/tex] are lin.dependent then one of a+b, b, c must be different from zero. SO, we can automatically conclude that

:[tex] av_1+b(v_1+v_2)+cv_3=0[/tex] has nontrivial sol, hence it it dependent set.

Please enlighten me, i am kind of confused?

Thnx in advance!

**Physics Forums | Science Articles, Homework Help, Discussion**

Join Physics Forums Today!

The friendliest, high quality science and math community on the planet! Everyone who loves science is here!

The friendliest, high quality science and math community on the planet! Everyone who loves science is here!

# Linearly dependent set of vectors?

**Physics Forums | Science Articles, Homework Help, Discussion**