B Log(x), an easy and useful way to calculate it

guifb99

½Logb(x2-1)≈logb(x)

This is an easy and useful way to calculate the log of any natural number, including primes, it won't ever give a precise result, obviously (because of the -1), but as "x2-1" will always have divisors smaller than "x", you can easily calculate the approximation by using the property that logc(a*b)=logc(a) + logc(b).

It could actually just be n-1logb(xn-k)≈logb(x) but it would be harder to calculate depending on which "k" or which "n" you use and won't be as useful for school purposes.

Obviously, since ½logb(x2)=logb(x), the closer "k" is to 0, the more precise the result will be. And the closer "n" is to infinity, also the more precise the result will be, since the value of "k" will become less and less significant as "xn" gets bigger.

*It's good to notice that for a "k" bigger than one, it will fail miserably.

BvU

Homework Helper
Hello guif,

How would you actually go about to calculate such a logarithm ? Can you give an example ? What if e.g. x = 23 ?

Stephen Tashi

The general idea is the approximation $f(x) \approx \frac{f(x-1) + f(x+1)}{2}$.

for $x > 1$ , $\log_b(x^2 -1) = \log_b((x-1)(x+1)) = \log_b(x-1) + \log_b(x+1)$

BvU

Homework Helper
So instead of calculating $\log 23$ I look up $\log 22$ and $\log 24$ and then average ?

mfb

jim mcnamara

Mentor
You still have to look up logarithms with your method. Basically if you have to look up two logarithms to get a third, you could have saved yourself work by simply just looking up the log you wanted first off. You are not saving anything, really.

Euler developed a simple way by hand using 4 properties of properties of logarithms. So learn how to do logs by hand, I did, it's fun.

dkotschessaa

You still have to look up logarithms with your method. Basically if you have to look up two logarithms to get a third, you could have saved yourself work by simply just looking up the log you wanted first off. You are not saving anything, really.

Euler developed a simple way by hand using 4 properties of properties of logarithms. So learn how to do logs by hand, I did, it's fun.:
https://www.fiziko.bureau42.com/teaching_tidbits/manual_logarithms.pdf [Broken]

-Dave K
(sorry)

Last edited by a moderator:

jim mcnamara

Mentor
I'm fixing it as we post !

Attachments

• 116 KB Views: 165
• 116 KB Views: 571

Mentor

Mark44

Mentor
½Logb(x2-1)≈logb(x)
For large x, $x^2 - 1 \approx x^2$, so $\log_b(x^2 - 1) \approx \log_b(x^2) = 2 \log_b(x)$. Your equation above comes immediately from this one.

For example, with x = 25, $\frac 1 2 \log(25^2 - 1) \approx 1.397592$ and $\log(25) \approx 1.39794$.

Last edited:

dkotschessaa

I'm fixing it as we post !
The one about square roots by hand is very cool also. We are never taught this stuff.

Matt E Gordon

Here I found way to find Solution Without Calculator. I should say to the approximate logarithm(base 10) of any number, you need to remember the above three values. And this method I used and worked for me. I am sharing it here.

"Log(x), an easy and useful way to calculate it"

Physics Forums Values

We Value Quality
• Topics based on mainstream science
• Proper English grammar and spelling
We Value Civility
• Positive and compassionate attitudes
• Patience while debating
We Value Productivity
• Disciplined to remain on-topic
• Recognition of own weaknesses
• Solo and co-op problem solving