Maximizing Area: Solving Quadratic Applications with Triangles and Rectangles

AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers around solving a problem involving the area of a house's front, which consists of a rectangle and a triangular roof. The initial equations proposed by the original poster were incorrect as they did not account for the total area of both the rectangle and the triangle. After clarification, it was established that the total area is 336 ft², leading to the correct formulation of the quadratic equation 6x² + 6x - 336 = 0. The solution yielded x = 7, which was verified to produce the correct area for the rectangle and the triangles combined. The importance of accurately interpreting the problem and drawing diagrams for clarity was emphasized throughout the discussion.
hackedagainanda
Messages
52
Reaction score
11
Homework Statement
The front face of a house is in the shape of a rectangle with a Queen post roof truss above. The length of the rectangular region is 3 times the height of the truss. The height of the rectangle is 2 ft more than the height of the truss. If the total area of the front of the house is 336 ft^2 determine the length and the width of the rectangular region
Relevant Equations
Area for rectangle: A = LW
Area for a triangle (1/2)bh
So the top of the structure is a triangle with height x. and the height of the rectangle is 2 + x, and the length is 3x.

I'm unsure where to go from here. I tried using the formula and getting 3x^2 + 6x +x = 3x^2 + 7x -336 =0 I applied the quadratic formula but it gave me non-integer solutions. I may be reading the problem wrong or not getting the right equation from the prompt.
 
  • Like
Likes Delta2
Physics news on Phys.org
1) Why do you think the answer needs to be an integer?
EDIT: The following is incorrect. The area given is for the entire side, including the triangle on top.
2) Why are you adding an extra x? All the information is about the length and width of a rectangle and the question asks about the area of the rectangle. I don't see the need for adding another x.
3x(x+2) = 3x^2+6x=336.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes sysprog
Hmm, @hackedagainanda, isn't your anwer numerically the same as that of @FactChecker? Doesn't 'whatever-336=0' mean the same thing as 'whatever=336'?
 
hackedagainanda said:
Homework Statement:: The front face of a house is in the shape of a rectangle with a Queen post roof truss above. The length of the rectangular region is 3 times the height of the truss. The height of the rectangle is 2 ft more than the height of the truss. If the total area of the front of the house is 336 ft^2 determine the length and the width of the rectangular region
Relevant Equations:: Area for rectangle: A = LW
Area for a triangle (1/2)bh

3x^2 + 6x +x = 3x^2 + 7x -336 =0
The business of "Queen post roof truss" is a red herring. The only thing important about the truss is its height, which we can call x. The height of the Queen posts (I had to look up "queen post truss") is irrelevant in this problem.
House.png

The equation in the OP does not represent the sum of the rectangular area and the area of the roof truss.
"If the total area of the front of the house is 336 ft^2..."

In my formulation of the problem, there are two integer solutions, one of which is negative.
FactChecker said:
3x(x+2) = 3x^2+6x=336.
This equation is incorrect also, as it doesn't include the area of the truss.
sysprog said:
Doesn't 'whatever-336=0' mean the same thing as 'whatever=336'?
Yes, but the OP and @FactChecker don't have the same equations.
 
  • Like
Likes Delta2, FactChecker and sysprog
Mark44 said:
Yes, but the OP and @FactChecker don't have the same equations.
Right, of course, but can't 'whatever' [represent / be substituted for] the lhs of either equation?
 
Mark44 said:
This equation is incorrect also, as it doesn't include the area of the truss.

Yes, but the OP and @FactChecker don't have the same equations.
Sorry. I stand corrected. I thought that the area of 336 was for the rectangle, but it is not. It is for the entire side, including the triangle on the top.
 
  • Like
Likes sysprog
sysprog said:
Right, of course, but can't 'whatever' [represent / be substituted for] the lhs of either equation?
Sure, and this is what I agreed with you on.
 
  • Like
Likes sysprog
FactChecker said:
1) Why do you think the answer needs to be an integer?
The other questions in this section usually say round to the nearest tenth, hundreths, etc. when its a non-integer.
Mark44 said:
The business of "Queen post roof truss" is a red herring. The only thing important about the truss is its height, which we can call x. The height of the Queen posts (I had to look up "queen post truss") is irrelevant in this problem.
View attachment 289182
The equation in the OP does not represent the sum of the rectangular area and the area of the roof truss.
"If the total area of the front of the house is 336 ft^2..."

In my formulation of the problem, there are two integer solutions, one of which is negative.

Can I get a hint at formulating the problem?
 
hackedagainanda said:
Can I get a hint at formulating the problem?
Look at the drawing I posted. In my drawing, x is the height of the truss. what are the dimensions of the rectangular part of the front of the house.

Again, the problem statement says this: "the total area of the front of the house is 336 ft^2..."
The front of the house includes the rectangular part and the area defined by the truss.
 
  • #10
The dimensions are 3x(x +2) and the truss is 2 triangles so its x(3x) so its 3x^2 + 3x^2 +6x = 336

Write in standard form and get 6x^2 +6x - 336 = 0 The quadratic formula gets me x = 7, and x = -8
 
  • #11
hackedagainanda said:
The dimensions are 3x(x +2) and the truss is 2 triangles so its x(3x) so its 3x^2 + 3x^2 +6x = 336

Write in standard form and get 6x^2 +6x - 336 = 0 The quadratic formula gets me x = 7, and x = -8
Obviously, x = -8 can't be a solution. Does the solution x = 7 produce the right area for the front of the house? You should always check your solution for these types of problems.
 
  • Like
Likes hackedagainanda
  • #12
It does check 3x 7 x (7 +2) = 21 x 9 = 189, + 3(7^2)= 147. 147 + 189 = 336. So the area of the rectangle is 189 ft^2.Thanks for the help, I'll have to remember draw diagrams on the test.
 
  • #13
hackedagainanda said:
It does check 3x 7 x (7 +2) = 21 x 9 = 189, + 3(7^2)= 147. 147 + 189 = 336. So the area of the rectangle is 189 ft^2.Thanks for the help, I'll have to remember draw diagrams on the test.
What's the combined area of your two triangles?
 
  • #14
SammyS said:
What's the combined area of your two triangles?
147 ft^2
 
  • #15
hackedagainanda said:
I'll have to remember draw diagrams on the test.
It's a good idea to draw a diagram for these kinds of problems, whether it's a test or not.
 
  • #16
hackedagainanda said:
147 ft^2
So then each triangle has an area of 73.5 ft2.

But with two triangles sitting on top of the rectangle, each would have a base of 21/2 = 10.5 ft and altitude of 7 ft. That gives an area of 73.5/2 =36.75 ft2 for each and a total are of 73.5 ft2 for the two triangles combined.

That does not add up to the required total area of 336 ft2.
 
  • #17
SammyS said:
So then each triangle has an area of 73.5 ft2.

But with two triangles sitting on top of the rectangle, each would have a base of 21/2 = 10.5 ft and altitude of 7 ft. That gives an area of 73.5/2 =36.75 ft2 for each and a total are of 73.5 ft2 for the two triangles combined.

That does not add up to the required total area of 336 ft2.
The 189 ft^2 is correct though... Which is the correct answer, but did I get the right answer for the wrong reason?
 
  • #18
hackedagainanda said:
The 189 ft^2 is correct though... Which is the correct answer
I don't think so. If 189 sq. ft. is the posted answer, whoever solved the problem is working a different one. I get an area for the rectangle part of the house front of 240 sq. ft.
 
  • #19
Is the quadratic 6x^2 + 6x - 336 = 0 the wrong equation?
 
  • #20
hackedagainanda said:
Is the quadratic 6x^2 + 6x - 336 = 0 the wrong equation?
Yes, it's wrong.
hackedagainanda said:
The dimensions are 3x(x +2) and the truss is 2 triangles so its x(3x) so its 3x^2 + 3x^2 +6x = 336

Write in standard form and get 6x^2 +6x - 336 = 0 The quadratic formula gets me x = 7, and x = -8
You're not very clear regarding the base and height for the triangles.

Start with an individual triangle. What is the expression for the base? What is the expression for the height?
 
  • #21
hackedagainanda said:
the truss is 2 triangles so its x(3x)
The width of each triangle being...?
 
  • #22
(1/2)x(1.5x) So I get 2(1/2)x(1.5x) so adding the area of the rectangle I get 3x^2 + 6x + 1.5x for a total of
4.5x^2 +6x - 336 = 0. The quadratic formula gets me 8, and - 28/3. The area of each triangle is (1/2)8 x 12 which is 48. The area of each triangle is 48 ft^2 both combined is 96 ft^2 and 96 ft^2 + 240 ft^2 = 336 ft ^2 so the answer checks.
 
Last edited:
  • #23
hackedagainanda said:
(1/2)x(1.5x) So I get 2(1/2)x(1.5x) so adding the area of the rectangle I get 3x^2 + 6x + 1.5x for a total of
4.5x +6x - 336 = 0. The quadratic formula gets me 8, and - 28/3. The area of each triangle is (1/2)8 x 12 which is 48. The area of each triangle is 48 ft^2 both combined is 96 ft^2 and 96 ft^2 + 240 ft^2 = 336 ft ^2 so the answer checks.
That's what I get, x = 8. (I didn't bother simplifying the negative solution.)

Small typo in your quadratic equation -- should be ##4.5x^2 + 6x - 336 = 0##.
 
  • Like
Likes hackedagainanda
  • #24
Thanks to everyone for your patience and help!
 
  • Like
Likes Delta2 and sysprog
Back
Top