Maximum electromagnetic field from current loops of different radii

  • Thread starter baby_1
  • Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Em Force
13 replies · 2K views · last reply
baby_1
Messages
159
Reaction score
16
Hello
1-here is a problem that want to specify which current loop has max electromagnetic intensity?(the correct choice is d)
Four labeled diagrams (a) to (d) of a vertical line with circular current loops above and below a dot, arrows showing loop directions; loop sizes vary between diagrams.

(Loop radius: small loop (r) big loop(2r))
so i think choice C is correct it because of this result
Four-panel diagram (d) of coaxial circular current loops on a vertical axis with arrows, then a block arrow to a superposition showing circulation symbols with plus signs and an equals sign, ending with one large loop and a small loop.

and
Three-panel diagram of two coaxial current loops of different radii around a vertical line, with an arrow between the first two panels, and a sum of circulation symbols below showing the field contributions of the small loops; labels include (c) and one of the small loop.


do i think correct or not?

2-for obtain electromagnetic filed we assume that current is from electron or proton?

Thanks
 
If you observe in c, the bigger loops cancel each other, and the smaller loops also. in+in+out+out=0.
 
Thanks dear PhysicoRaj
But as I do the right hand rule for each big loop i found the MF of each of them is out of the page and they add to each other not cancel.I show each MF direction via hollow circles and the Bold.
Diagram of a circular current loop with an arrow showing current direction counterclockwise, a right hand gripping the loop, and blue circles with crosses marking field B pointing out of the page, inside and outside the loop.
 
Last edited:
baby_1 said:
Thanks dear PhysicoRaj
But as I do the right hand rule for each big loop i found the MF of each of them is out of the page and they add to each other not cancel.I show each MF direction via hollow circles and the Bold.
Diagram of a circular loop with a current arrow i running counterclockwise, with a hand grasping the loop, inside a field of dots and crosses marking out-of-page and into-page magnetic field B.

Do that for small loops also and you will find that they cancel. c can't be the answer. What do you think about a?
 
Hello
dear PhysicoRaj
yes in choice a two small loop cancel their MF.
Diagram (a): a vertical straight wire with two circular loops around it, one above and one below a dot on the wire, with arrows on the loops showing current direction; a circle with a dot and a circle with a cross sit to the left of the wire, marking out-of-page and into-page fields.


but as you see the choice 'c' the current direction of each loop is different and has different MF direction.
 
baby_1 said:
yes in choice a two small loop cancel their MF.
How? Aren't the currents in the same direction?
 
baby_1 said:
but as you see the choice 'c' the current direction of each loop is different and has different MF direction.

So shouldn't the MF in different directions cancel?
 
baby_1, magnetic field is a vector field and has to be added vectorially. To put that, fields in the same direction add up and fields in the opposite directions tend to cancel out.
When you have currents in the same direction, then the produced magnetic fields are also in the same direction and add up.
When currents flow in opposite directions, the produced magnetic fields are also opposite in direction and they cancel out.
 
Hello
I try to explain more about choice 'c'
we separate choice 'c' and do Spperpostition.
the MF of two small loop is going into page(am I right?)
Diagram of two circular loops with arrows on a vertical axis, plus a dot and two circled crosses to the right, showing current directions.

so it increase amount of MF intensity(B1+B2)
and the MF of two large loop is going out of page(am I right?)
Diagram of two pairs of circular current loops coaxial with a vertical line, one pair larger than the other, each with an arrow showing current direction, and a dot and circle-with-dot symbols at right.

(B3+B4)

as we know the amount of B3 and B4 is smaller than B1 and B2 it because of their loop radius
Formula B = μI / 2R, with B on the left, the magnetic field of a circular loop, and μ, I and R as the permeability, current and radius on the right.

(radius of big loops is 2r and radius of small loops is r) so B1+B2 can remove the effect of large loops and remain some MF into page direction(am I right).

if we assume r=1 and 2r=2 we have(we ignore constants(m0/2))
B1=1/1
B2=1/1
B'=B1+B2=2(into page)

B3=1/2
B4=1/2

B''=B3+B4=1(out of page)

BT=B'-B''=1(into page)

now for choice 'd' we can do same approach
Diagram (d) with two sets of concentric current loops on a vertical axis, an arrow to a decomposition into dot-and-cross circles summed to one big loop, labelled we can assume only one big loop.

B1=1/1(into page)
B2=1/1(out of page)
B'=0

B3(large loop)=1/2

Bt=1/2

so choice 'c' is bigger than choice 'd'
 
Rather than thinking in terms of into or out of the page, think like, up or down the axis. Every picture shows an axis right? And you are asked to probably find in which choice the field has greatest intensity at the point indicated as a thick dot on the axis.

See (a): both currents are turning clockwise. So the field is added.

See (b): the upper current flows clockwise whereas the bottom one anticlockwise. So the magnetic fields are opposite and cancel out.

See (c): the two small currents are opposite and their magnetic fields cancel. Similarily the two bigger currents are opposite and their magnetic fields cancel.

See (d): both of the small currents are in anticlockwise direction and their fields add up. Plus the large current flows in same direction too! Hence all the three add up!
 
Thank you so much PhysicoRaj for your approach
I just want to learn more about electromagnetic via mathematical way.so i asked thos question here about my approach.
is it possible to tell me about my approach?and my mistakes?

As I try to send you a private message that what reference and book you suggest to me about your approach and easiest ways to obtain electromagnetic force and filed effect , it seems you locked your account.If there is no problem could you introduce me some book and reference that you think it is suitable for me?
 
There was no major difference in the methods used by you and me. You just needed some refinement in the method.
I am no expert in suggesting study materials, so I advice you to post it in the 'physics learning materials' forum: https://www.physicsforums.com/forumdisplay.php?f=160 .
Good luck.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Hello
Dear PhysicoRaj
Thanks for your response.

anybody else could help me on my approach and what is my problem?