Discussion Overview
The discussion centers on the feasibility of measuring the diameter of stars in galaxies beyond the Milky Way using current technology. It explores both direct and indirect measurement methods, the limitations of various astronomical instruments, and the distances at which these measurements can be accurately made.
Discussion Character
- Technical explanation
- Debate/contested
- Exploratory
Main Points Raised
- Some participants suggest that while direct measurement of star diameters in other galaxies is not possible, indirect methods using color and light output can infer diameters.
- There is a question about the maximum distance from Earth at which star diameters can be directly measured, with a participant seeking an approximate distance threshold for direct measurement versus indirect methods.
- One participant details the capabilities of the Hubble's Advanced Camera for Surveys, noting that it can measure the diameter of a giant star at 120 light years with a 10% accuracy, but requires closer proximity for smaller stars.
- Another participant discusses the resolution capabilities of ground-based interferometers, mentioning that they can resolve stars like Betelgeuse at significant distances, potentially up to the edge of the galaxy.
- There is mention of the current limitations of the SUSI interferometer, with a participant noting its baseline capacity and speculating on future upgrades that could enhance measurement capabilities.
- Participants discuss the differences between various interferometers, highlighting that many are designed for imaging rather than just measuring diameters, and that engineering and cost are factors in their capabilities.
Areas of Agreement / Disagreement
Participants express varying views on the capabilities of different instruments and the distances at which they can measure star diameters. There is no consensus on the maximum distance for direct measurements, and the discussion remains unresolved regarding the effectiveness of different methods and technologies.
Contextual Notes
Limitations include the dependence on the specific capabilities of instruments, the varying definitions of "direct measurement," and the unresolved nature of the maximum distances for accurate measurements.