Mom sues preschool for damaging 4 yo Ivy League chances

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around a lawsuit filed by a mother against a preschool, claiming that the institution's curriculum harmed her daughter's chances of gaining admission to elite private schools and potentially Ivy League universities. The conversation touches on themes of educational standards, the high cost of preschool, and societal pressures regarding early childhood education.

Discussion Character

  • Debate/contested
  • Conceptual clarification
  • Meta-discussion

Main Points Raised

  • Some participants express disbelief at the $19,000 tuition for preschool, questioning who would pay such an amount.
  • Others argue that if the mother paid for a service that was not delivered, seeking a refund could be justified.
  • Several comments reflect a sentiment that the lawsuit highlights broader issues in society regarding the pressures of early education and the competitive nature of school admissions.
  • Some participants suggest that the emphasis on preschool as a determinant for future success is misguided, viewing it as more of a social status issue than a practical necessity.
  • A few contributors mention that high daycare costs in urban areas like NYC may make the lawsuit seem less absurd when considering the context of childcare expenses.
  • One participant shares a personal perspective on the pressures of preparing children for competitive school admissions, acknowledging the high stakes involved.
  • Comments also touch on the absurdity of the situation, with some expressing a desire for children to have a more carefree childhood rather than being subjected to early academic pressures.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants generally disagree on the validity of the lawsuit, with some viewing it as a reasonable response to perceived educational shortcomings, while others consider it frivolous and indicative of societal issues. There is no consensus on whether the preschool's approach was adequate or whether the lawsuit is justified.

Contextual Notes

There are varying assumptions about the role of preschool in a child's future educational success, and the discussion reflects differing opinions on the appropriateness of suing an educational institution over perceived failures in early childhood education.

  • #61
MJay82 said:
Because the education we've been giving our children in America for decades/centuries is largely inadequate, or at the VERY least not as good as it could/should be? Be the change.

I couldn't care less about being part of that change for a doomed species.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #62
nismaratwork said:
I couldn't care less about being part of that change for a doomed species.

I hear you and can't fault you for it. Still, some of us must try. :)
 
  • #63
MJay82 said:
I hear you and can't fault you for it. Still, some of us must try. :)

In that, I wish you and all teachers the best of luck, not in the least for having to deal with parents...