Need some tips about solving confusing Stoic Problem

  • Thread starter Thread starter Lori
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Confusing Tips
Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around a chemistry homework problem involving the calculation of the mass of iron(III) chloride (FeCl3) needed to achieve a specific chloride ion concentration in a solution containing calcium chloride (CaCl2). The scope includes mathematical reasoning, stoichiometry, and molarity concepts.

Discussion Character

  • Homework-related
  • Mathematical reasoning
  • Technical explanation

Main Points Raised

  • One participant expresses confusion about how to convert given concentrations and volumes to find the mass of FeCl3 needed.
  • Another participant suggests calculating the moles of chloride ions required to reach the desired concentration and determining how many moles of FeCl3 are needed to provide those moles.
  • A participant points out that the molarity of chloride in the existing CaCl2 solution is double that of CaCl2 due to its dissociation.
  • There is a discussion about the need to find the molarity of chloride in the existing solution before calculating how many more moles are needed.
  • Several participants emphasize the importance of understanding the relationship between moles and molarity in solving the problem.
  • A participant proposes creating a before-after matrix to organize the information and calculations needed to solve the problem.
  • Another participant confirms the final calculation of 7.08 grams of FeCl3, noting that in practice, the anhydrous form is rarely used, and the hexahydrate form would require a different mass.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants generally agree on the approach to solving the problem but express varying levels of understanding and clarity regarding the calculations involved. There is no consensus on the initial confusion, but a collaborative effort to clarify the steps is evident.

Contextual Notes

Participants mention the importance of considering the form of FeCl3 used in practical applications, highlighting that the hexahydrate form would affect the mass needed.

Lori

Homework Statement


What mass of iron(3) chloride should be added to 450 ml of 0.132 M CaCl2 to give a solution with final chloride concentration of 0.555M

There are a lot of numbers, and I get confused on how to convert it to get mass of iron(3) chloride!

Homework Equations


M = n/L

The Attempt at a Solution


? g iron(3) chloride (162.2 g/mol)
.450 L of 0.132 M CaCl2 gives 0.0594 mols
0.555 M Cl- = 0.555 mols/L

I know the mole to mole ratio we would use is 2:3 but like, i get stuck at trying to start with the right numbers in my dimensional analyst...

my attempt:

0.555 mols/ L Cl- * (0.45 L CaCl2) * (3 mols Cl/2molsCl) *(1mol FeCl3/3molsCl ) = 0.12 (which is wrong).
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Firstly, you must find how many mols of Cl- you must add to the existing solution to achieve chloride concentration of 0,555 M.

Then, you must think how many moles of FeCl3 are needed to provide these mols.

Finally, using the molar mass you can calculate the respective mass of FeCl3.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Lori and Chestermiller
Even before that you'd have to know what is the molarity of chloride in the existing CaCl2 solution?
 
Of course,

CaCl2 disassociates by the reaction:

CaCl2 ## \to ## Ca2+ + 2Cl-.

So, the molarity of chloride is two times the molarity of CaCl2. Right?
 
Right enough - so give it a number.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: DoItForYourself
DoItForYourself said:
Firstly, you must find how many mols of Cl- you must add to the existing solution to achieve chloride concentration of 0,555 M.

Then, you must think how many moles of FeCl3 are needed to provide these mols.

Finally, using the molar mass you can calculate the respective mass of FeCl3.
I figured out that there are 0.1188 mols of Cl- in the solution but how do I know how many moles Cl to achieve .555 M cl?
 
epenguin said:
Even before that you'd have to know what is the molarity of chloride in the existing CaCl2 solution?
Hi. I just started the problem again and I'm still confused. I got the moles of Cl that's in the current solution but I'm not sure how to find how many more moles we need to get the .555 M Cl concentration
 
Typically all you need in such situations is subtraction.
 
Borek said:
Typically all you need in such situations is subtraction.
I know that but isn't. .555 M like .555 mols per liter? How can I get mols so that I can subtract it by .1188
 
  • #10
You can think in moles or you can think in molarity which is as you say moles per litre, and usually you will have to go a bit back and forth between them.

There is not just one right way. However I would find just a bit easier since you are given a molarity to start with, and you aim to finish with another molarity, to answer my question with molarity of chloride 0.132 × 2 = 0.264 M. You are asked to achieve final molarity of 0.555 M - so what's the molarity in chloride you need to add - see Borek, and it does that make sense?
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Lori
  • #11
epenguin said:
You can think in moles or you can think in molarity which is as you say moles per litre, and usually you will have to go a bit back and forth between them.

There is not just one right way. However I would find just a bit easier since you are given a molarity to start with, and you aim to finish with another molarity, to answer my question with molarity of chloride 0.132 × 2 = 0.264 M. You are asked to achieve final molarity of 0.555 M - so what's the molarity in chloride you need to add - see Borek, and it does that make sense?
So. I should start with .555 M of chlorine ?
 
  • #12
I'm am still lost ;(. Here's what I got

Untitled-1.jpg
 

Attachments

  • Untitled-1.jpg
    Untitled-1.jpg
    47.7 KB · Views: 553
  • #13
Sorry I just can't read that. In future if you must post Photos of homework pages, which is discouraged and certainly not necessary for such a simple problem as this, please use an app like the free DocScanHD to render them readable and post them the right way up.

OK, so for a litre you want there to be 0.555 moles of chloride, you have got 0.264 moles of chloride (see #10) - how many more moles of chloride do you need there to be in that litre? How difficult is that?
 
  • #14
Hey Lori! :)

I have trouble reading what you've got as well, and moreover, I have trouble making sense what everything is, and how they are connected.

To solve a problem like this, it usually helps to write down all given information first, and make a before-after matrix.

Something like:
$$\begin{array}{ll} V=450\text{ mL}\\
c(CaCl_2)=0.132\text{ mol/L}\\
c_{after}(Cl^-)=0.555\text{ mol/L}\\
M(FeCl_3)=162.2\text{ g/mol}\\
\begin{array}{|c|c|c|}
\hline
&Before & After & Delta \\
\hline
c(Cl^-) & ? & 0.555\text{ mol/L} & - \\
n(Cl^-) & ? & ? & ?\\
n(FeCl_3) & ? & - & -\\
\hline
\end{array} \\
m(FeCl_3) =?\end{array}$$
Relevant formulas:
- moles are concentration times volume (##n=c\cdot V##),
- mass is moles times molar mass (##m=n\cdot M##).

Can we find all the question marks?
 
Last edited:
  • #15
I like Serena said:
Hey Lori! :)

I have trouble reading what you've got as well, and moreover, I have trouble making sense what everything is, and how they are connected.

To solve a problem like this, it usually helps to write down all given information first, and make a before-after matrix.

Something like:
$$V=450\text{ mL}\\
c(CaCl_2)=0.132\text{ mol/L}\\
c_{after}(Cl^-)=0.555\text{ mol/L}\\
M(FeCl_3)=162.2\text{ g/mol}\\
\begin{array}{|c|c|c|}
\hline
&Before & After & Delta \\
\hline
c(Cl^-) & ? & 0.555\text{ mol/L} & - \\
n(Cl^-) & ? & ? & ?\\
n(FeCl_3) & ? & - & -\\
\hline
\end{array} \\
m(FeCl_3) =?$$
Relevant formulas:
- moles are concentration times volume (##n=c\cdot V##),
- mass is moles times molar mass (##m=n\cdot M##).

Can we find all the question marks?
I'm Sorry, but I expected that there would be confusion cause my calculation is all over the place! I will follow your strategy. I'll let you know what I get!
 
  • #16
epenguin said:
You can think in moles or you can think in molarity which is as you say moles per litre, and usually you will have to go a bit back and forth between them.

There is not just one right way. However I would find just a bit easier since you are given a molarity to start with, and you aim to finish with another molarity, to answer my question with molarity of chloride 0.132 × 2 = 0.264 M. You are asked to achieve final molarity of 0.555 M - so what's the molarity in chloride you need to add - see Borek, and it does that make sense?
Ok, i got that we need 0.291 mols Cl- /literOh i see! We need .291 mols Cl- /liter, but we have 0.450 L of CaCl2, so if we multiply these numbers together , we get the mols we need of Cl-. With 0.13095 mols Cl-, calculate moles of FeCl3 we need by using ration 1 fecl3 to 3 moles cl-. Converting to grams in FeCl3 with molar mass, we get 7.08 grams?

Is it is 7.08 grams of FeCl3? :OI'm pretty sure i spent like 3 hours on this problem, but i realize that i just need to think about and ask the same questions that you guys asked. Sigh!

Thanks for your guys patients >.<
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #17
7.08 g of FeCl3 it is.

Lori said:
i just need to think about and ask the same questions that you guys asked

We don't ask them without reason.

Note: in the real lab you would have serious problems finding anhydrous FeCl3, as this compound is typically sold as hexahydrate (FeCl3⋅6H2O). That means you would need almost 12 g of the solid.
 

Similar threads

Replies
5
Views
3K
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
11K
Replies
5
Views
9K