Discussion Overview
The discussion revolves around performing statistical checks in MCNP5, specifically focusing on the use of the PRINT card and mesh tallies. Participants seek assistance with syntax, troubleshooting errors, and plotting results from MCNP simulations, covering both theoretical and practical aspects of using the software.
Discussion Character
- Technical explanation
- Debate/contested
- Homework-related
- Mathematical reasoning
- Experimental/applied
Main Points Raised
- One participant inquires about the placement and format of the PRINT card for statistical checks in MCNP5, specifically with F4mesh tallies.
- Another participant suggests that the PRINT command is detailed in the user manual and mentions that it should be placed in the data section, with options for printing specific tables.
- A participant reports that their MCNP crashes when adding the PRINT card, indicating a possible syntax error in their input file.
- Suggestions are made to check for common syntax errors, such as extra or missing blank lines, line length, and non-accepted characters.
- Several participants request assistance with plotting color legends for mesh tallies and discuss methods for outputting data for visualization.
- Another participant describes their experience using a 3D mesh tally over a lattice structure in MCNPX, noting issues with obtaining non-zero results in their output files.
- One user mentions successfully using FMESH in MCNP6 but encounters issues with obtaining results in MCNP5.
- Another participant asks about creating a batch file to automate running simulations with varying energy bins, seeking guidance on how to implement this in MCNP.
- Multiple users report installation issues with MCNP6, specifically related to missing library files, and seek advice on resolving these errors.
- A participant expresses a need for help in rebinning energy bins for a neutron surface source using MCNP5, asking for recommendations on the appropriate tally to use.
Areas of Agreement / Disagreement
Participants express various challenges and seek solutions, but there is no consensus on specific troubleshooting steps or methods for statistical checks, as multiple approaches and experiences are shared without resolution.
Contextual Notes
Participants mention specific versions of MCNP (MCNP5 and MCNPX) and various configurations for mesh tallies, indicating that solutions may depend on the version and specific setup used. Some discussions involve unresolved syntax errors and troubleshooting steps that are not universally applicable.
Who May Find This Useful
This discussion may be useful for users of MCNP5 and MCNPX, particularly those involved in simulations requiring statistical checks, mesh tallies, and troubleshooting common errors in input files.