hey(adsbygoogle = window.adsbygoogle || []).push({});

Gonna get straight to the point. I need to establish the probability difference between two probabilities p_1 and p_2 at 95%. Its the two probabilites that a cabin hook will hold for a certain force (25kN).

two samples, each with sizes "the originals" n_1=107, "cheap pirated ones" n_2=92. y_i are the amount of hooks which managed to successfully keep their acts together at 25kN for resp. sample

y_1=84 of which Y_1 is Bin(107,p_1) ≈ N(107*p_1, sqrt(107*p_1*q_1)) where q_1=1-p_1

and

y_2=12 of which Y_2 is Bin(92, p_2) ≈ N(92*p_2, sqrt(92*p_2*q_2))

now p_1 and p_2 can be estimated as follows:

^p_1 = y_1/107 which is an observation from ^P_1 ≈ N(p_1, sqrt((p_1*q_1)/107)

and ^p_2=y_2/92 obs ^P_2 ≈ N(p_2, sqrt((p_2*q_2)/92)

which gives us the estimated probability difference of:

^P_1-^P_2 ≈N(p_1-p_2, sqrt((p_1*q_1/107)+(p_2*q_2/92)))

which means you get the variable:

(^P_1-^P_2-(p_1-p_2))/sqrt((^P_1*^Q_1/107)+(^P_2*^Q_2/92)) ≈ N(0,1)

closing this stuff with z=z_0.975=1.96 from the normal dist. table gives me

INTERVAL_(p_1-p_2) = (^p_1-^p_2 -+ 1.96*sqrt((^p_1*^q_1/107)+(^p_2*^q_2/92)))=(0.55, 0.76)

This solution is supposedly correct and all I need is someone to help me understand the following:

1. When you subtract two stocastic variablesyou subtract the expected values from each other which I get, but the standard deviation is different... it becomes the sqrt of the sum of the independent stocastic variables standard deviations?

2. Why is the standard dev of the stocastic variable ^P_1 sqrt((p_1*q_1)/n_1)? cant you just call it σ_1? Are they the same? And is that always the case? Probability of something happening times 1- that probability through the sample size is equal to σ^2?

3. Why do you use the 97.5% probability when the question originally stated 95%? I know you use 1-α/2 to get there but Ive never understood WHEN you can just go with 95% and when you have to use 97.5, for F distributions it seems going with 95% is ok even with 2 samples

4. Why do you use a Binomial distribution for this kind of problem?

would be pretty much amazing if anyone could help out with any or all of these questions, Im a donkey when it comes to math stat. thanks

**Physics Forums | Science Articles, Homework Help, Discussion**

Dismiss Notice

Join Physics Forums Today!

The friendliest, high quality science and math community on the planet! Everyone who loves science is here!

The friendliest, high quality science and math community on the planet! Everyone who loves science is here!

# Probably (yea I know, hilarious) easy qs about Bin and Normal distributions

**Physics Forums | Science Articles, Homework Help, Discussion**