MHB Proof of Sets: Proving (i) and (ii)

  • Thread starter Thread starter Mathick
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Proof Sets
Click For Summary
The discussion focuses on proving two statements about power sets. It is concluded that statement (i), which claims that if Z = X ∪ Y, then P(Z) = P(X) ∪ P(Y), is false, as demonstrated by a counterexample. Conversely, statement (ii), asserting that if Z = X ∩ Y, then P(Z) = P(X) ∩ P(Y), is true, supported by logical reasoning about subset relationships. The participants agree on the validity of these conclusions based on their examples and proofs. Understanding these properties of power sets is essential in set theory.
Mathick
Messages
23
Reaction score
0
If $X$ is a set, then the power set $P(X)$ of a set is the set of all subsets of $X$.

I need to decide whether the following statements are true or false and prove it:
(i) If $Z = X \cup Y$ , then $P(Z) = P(X) \cup P(Y)$.

(ii) If $Z = X \cap Y$ , then $P(Z) = P(X) \cap P(Y)$.

By examples I think that (ii) is true but (i) is false. However, I have no idea how to prove it.

Note: Example which I used was: $X=\left\{a,b\right\}$ and $Y=\left\{b,c\right\}$.

(i) $Z = X \cup Y =\left\{a,b,c\right\}$ , so $P(Z) = \left\{\left\{\right\},\left\{a\right\},\left\{b\right\},\left\{c\right\},\left\{a,b\right\},\left\{a,c\right\},\left\{b,c\right\},\left\{a,b,c\right\}\right\}$ .

However, $P(X) \cup P(Y) = \left\{\left\{\right\},\left\{a\right\},\left\{b\right\},\left\{c\right\},\left\{a,b\right\},\left\{b,c\right\}\right\}$.

That's why I disagree with a statement (i).

(ii) $Z = X \cap Y =\left\{b\right\}$ , so $P(Z) = \left\{\left\{\right\},\left\{b\right\}\right\}$ . However, $P(X) \cap P(Y) = \left\{\left\{\right\},\left\{b\right\}\right\}$ as well.

That's why I think a statement (ii) is true.

I would be grateful for help!
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Mathick said:
That's why I disagree with a statement (i).
You are absolutely correct.

If $Z=X\cap Y$, then $A\subseteq Z\iff A\subseteq X\land A\subseteq Y$ for any $A$, which means that $A\in P(Z)\iff A\in P(X)\land A\in P(Y)\iff A\in P(X)\cap P(Y)$.
 
Hello, I'm joining this forum to ask two questions which have nagged me for some time. They both are presumed obvious, yet don't make sense to me. Nobody will explain their positions, which is...uh...aka science. I also have a thread for the other question. But this one involves probability, known as the Monty Hall Problem. Please see any number of YouTube videos on this for an explanation, I'll leave it to them to explain it. I question the predicate of all those who answer this...