QI-Style Question: What's Wrong with this Diagram?

  • Thread starter LtIvan
  • Start date
6 replies · 3K views · last reply
LtIvan
Messages
40
Reaction score
6
Allo, wes geo hal,

Here is a little question I devised is the style of the British reality quiz series QI hosted by Stephen Fry.
The most obvious wrong answer will result in loss of points and correct answer gets points.
Still from the QI quiz show: a man in a dark jacket and red shirt sits at a desk with his head bowed, in front of a backdrop of circular panels covered with handwritten-style equations, with the caption "oh, bother."


Question: Is this diagram correct? If not, what is the error.
Hand-drawn diagram with two labelled cones: STALAGMITE above an inverted V with curved growth lines, and STALACTITE below an upward-pointing V with vertical streaks.


Reply with your answer...

The will be a prize...maybe...if I think of something...
 
All you have to remember is that the one on the ground has a G and the one on the ceiling a C.
 
We always remembered that the stalactite needs to stick "tight" to the ceiling.
 
Wait so your answer is the labels are mixed up?...

Dark photo of a blue-lit circular stage with a shadowy figure in the centre, a glowing red and white spotlight above, and the words KLAXON! KLAXON! KLAXON! in large white letters across the bottom.


WRONG!

That is not the answer...

Try again

I do not think you understand the rules; you need to give a straight forward answer, not an anecdote that gives a vague response. Perhaps you need to have watch QI to understand.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: billy_joule
LtIvan said:
Question: Is this diagram correct? If not, what is the error.
The answer to the first question is "No." Several people have responded that stalactites hang from the ceiling of a cave, while stalagmites grow upward from the cave's floor. I don't see that there were any "vague responses."

What's your point here?
 
The answer to the first question is "No."

Reference https://www.physicsforums.com/threads/a-qi-styled-question.899022/

Wait so your answer is the labels are mixed up?... WRONG! That is not the answer...

I might as well give the answer awayAnswer: The lettering is upside down; the diagram is upside down. The diagram is correct, just that the labels are upside down.Get it? It is supposed to be a trick question. The trap is that you answer that the diagram is incorrect and the labels are mixed up.
It is suppose to be like the TV show QI where a lot of the questions are trick ones.

I just posted this as a fun quiz to see if anyone gets it

Wes geo hal
 
LtIvan said:
Answer: The lettering is upside down; the diagram is upside down. The diagram is correct, just that the labels are upside down.
This is just plain silly.
Thread closed.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Evo