Quantum physics explanation problem

Join the discussion
Registration is free. Ask a follow-up in this thread, or start your own.
2 replies · 2K views
hawkdron496
Messages
19
Reaction score
3
i have a friend and i am trying to explain to him that until it interacts with something it is evrywhere and no where but has more of a probability in being in place a than place b or c but until it interacts we don't know so there for it is evrywhere. that is the concept as i understand it. he says it is in one spot but has probability of being evrywhere who is right and if me how do i convince him?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
What is "it" referring to?
 
hawkdron496 said:
i have a friend and i am trying to explain to him that until it interacts with something it is evrywhere and no where but has more of a probability in being in place a than place b or c but until it interacts we don't know so there for it is evrywhere. that is the concept as i understand it. he says it is in one spot but has probability of being evrywhere who is right and if me how do i convince him?

We don't have an answer yet Hawkdron496.

For example there is an (quantum) interpretation that posits:

The photon/particle/electron passes through one slit (in a single particle double slit experiment) and its (probability) wave function "passes" through both. And then the wave-functions interfere.

This would slightly favor our friend's idea. Or you could find an interpretation that tends to favor your idea.

Or you could ask him to treat you to ice cream or pizza or whatever... if you were to provide him with an interpretation that favors his idea...;)

What we know is that some of our equations and mathematics (the concept of probability wave-function and its propagation) works very well.

We don't know yet how to interpret the mathematics "physically/in-reality"