Rod sliding on perpendicular rails: why is my velocity triangle method wrong?

  • Thread starter subhradeep mahata
  • Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Rod Sliding
7 replies · 3K views · last reply
subhradeep mahata
Messages
120
Reaction score
13

Homework Statement


Two particles A and B are connected by a rigid rod AB which slides along two mutually perpendicular rails as shown.
Sketch of a rod AB leaning against a vertical wall with a right angle at the base, labelled A on the wall and B on the floor; angle H is marked at B, and a bracket labelled x spans the horizontal distance and a bracket labelled y spans the vertical height.

H is the angle between point B and the horizontal rod. At an instant, when H=30°, the velocity of B is 10m/s towards left, and velocity of A is upwards. Find the velocity of A at that instant.

Homework Equations

The Attempt at a Solution


Now, I don't know if it is a rubbish method or not, I tried to solve it by forming a vector triangle as shown.
Hand-drawn velocity triangle: a vertical solid arrow labelled Va, a horizontal arrow labelled Vb pointing left, and a dashed hypotenuse with angle H marked at the lower right vertex.

(where Vb and Va are velocities of B and A at that instant)
Now, Va=Vb * tan 30° = 10/√3 m/s
But the correct answer according to my book is 10√3 m/s.
I don't want you to post the exact solution, but I request you to point out what went wrong in my method. Thanks.
 
Attachments
  • Sketch of a rod AB leaning against a vertical wall with a right angle at the base, labelled A on the wall and B on the floor; angle H is marked at B, and a bracket labelled x spans the horizontal distance and a bracket labelled y spans the vertical height.
    upload_2019-1-18_10-6-30.png
    21.7 KB · Views: 797
  • Hand-drawn velocity triangle: a vertical solid arrow labelled Va, a horizontal arrow labelled Vb pointing left, and a dashed hypotenuse with angle H marked at the lower right vertex.
    upload_2019-1-18_10-11-41.png
    22.4 KB · Views: 572
subhradeep mahata said:
point out what went wrong in my method.
You do not provide a reason as to why it should be right. Without some basis, it is just a guess.

The trick with these kinematic problems is to think about the lengths that stay constant. In this case it is the length of the rod.
What does that tell you about the components of the two velocities in the direction of the rod?
 
Okay, so the component of the velocities of b and a in the direction of the rod are 10 cos30° and -xcos60° respectively where x is velocity of a. But I don't understand how they are related to the length of rod being constant.
 
subhradeep mahata said:
Okay, so the component of the velocities of b and a in the direction of the rod are 10 cos30° and -xcos60° respectively where x is velocity of a. But I don't understand how they are related to the length of rod being constant.
Suppose B were moving at that speed in that direction (towards A), but A does not move. What would happen to the rod?
 
Ganit said:
Pythagoras + calculus = solution of ur problem
No, it's easier than that.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Ganit
subhradeep mahata said:
Okay, so the component of the velocities of b and a in the direction of the rod are 10 cos30° and -xcos60° respectively where x is velocity of a. But I don't understand how they are related to the length of rod being constant.
Try thinking that there is no rod but the there is constraint on particles 'A' an 'B' to move in such a way to keep distance between them constant then what would that Constraint be
 
Ganit said:
Try thinking that there is no rod but the there is constraint on particles 'A' an 'B' to move in such a way to keep distance between them constant then what would that Constraint be
Hello @Ganit .
:welcome:

@haruspex is giving help appropriate for the OP who apparently is a High School student.

It may be that speaking in terms of "constraints", etc. is over OP's head.