SciFi utilization of mini-black holes?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Noisy Rhysling
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Holes Scifi
Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the creative utilization of mini-black holes (MBHs) in science fiction narratives. Participants explore various fictional scenarios where MBHs are employed for different purposes, including energy generation, weaponry, and plot devices in movies and literature.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Conceptual clarification
  • Debate/contested

Main Points Raised

  • One participant recounts a story from 1964 where a mini black hole threatens Earth, leading to a character profiting from its containment by creating a vacuum.
  • Another mentions a Larry Niven story where a scientist uses a small black hole as a weapon by charging it with ionized material.
  • Some participants discuss the theoretical potential of small black holes to convert matter into Hawking Radiation, suggesting this could serve as an efficient energy source, as depicted in Star Trek.
  • References to the movie "Event Horizon" are made, with participants sharing humorous observations about its scientific inaccuracies.
  • One participant describes a plot element from the 2009 Star Trek movie involving "red matter" that could create black holes within planets.
  • In "Andromeda," antagonists use "point singularity projectors" to fire tiny black holes at enemy ships, with participants commenting on the show's lack of technological explanation.
  • Several humorous and imaginative scenarios are shared, including a whimsical image of a character using a mini-black hole as a weapon in a cartoonish context.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express a variety of creative uses for mini-black holes in science fiction, with no consensus on which portrayal is most plausible or effective. The discussion remains open-ended with multiple competing ideas and interpretations.

Contextual Notes

Some claims rely on speculative interpretations of black hole physics and the narrative liberties taken in science fiction. The discussion includes references to various fictional works without resolving the scientific accuracy of the concepts presented.

Noisy Rhysling
Messages
999
Reaction score
345
Okay, I have to admit that this was my first encounter with the term "black hole", c. 1964.

In the story I read a mini black hole (MBH) somehow made it to Earth was was devouring ... Montana? ... and there were fears that it would eventually swallow the whole (not "hole") world. There were various schemes proposed to deal with it, but one guy came forward and said he'd solve the problem for free if he could be granted sole ownership of the thing and any benefits accrued from it. The powers that be gave him the rights based on performance and he spent a lot of money encapsulating it, preventing further erosion of the planet.

So how did this benefit him financially? The last scene in the story had scientists and industry lining up to attach their devices to the containment unit. When the right valves were opened the air was sucked out of the machines and a practically perfect vacuum was produced. Apparently there was quite a line waiting their turn.

So, what's your favorite "creative" use of black holes in scifi stories?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
In one of Larry Niven's stories, a scientist found a small black hole and started dropping highly ionized material into it until it had built up a significant charge. Then he was able to wield it with a giant electromagnet, and use it as a nasty weapon, swallowing passing ships whole without a trace.
 
In theory a small black hole could turn matter completely into Hawking Radiation. The smaller the black hole the higher the output. That could be a very efficient energy source. This idea was used in Star Trek: The Romulan spaceships are powered with artificial singularities.
 
"Event Horizon" used a black hole, IIRC. I understand that's still in beta?
 
DaveC426913 said:
In one of Larry Niven's stories, a scientist found a small black hole and started dropping highly ionized material into it until it had built up a significant charge. Then he was able to wield it with a giant electromagnet, and use it as a nasty weapon, swallowing passing ships whole without a trace.
A part of the plot of this story revolved around how Niven's hyperspace drive worked. Ship that tried to use hyperdrive while too deep in a gravity well would disappear without a trace. The antagonist is this story had learned that the mini black hole crated a sharp enough gravity gradient to cause just the hyperdrive engine to vanish, dropping the rest of the ship back into normal space and crippling it so that he could pillage it before dumping the remains into the black hole.

Niven also used the idea of the quantum black hole in another story which involved the discovery of an abandoned extraterrestrial base on Mars. One of the pieces of equipment left behind was thought to be a gravitational wave generator which used a micro black hole.
 
Interstellar the movie...
 
EnumaElish said:
Interstellar the movie...
Good call. I have yet to watch that movie with the captions on so I can understand everything they say.

BTW, with regard to "Event Horizon", it just came up on NetFlix, so I've giving it another run. One good howler right at the start: "When the ion engine kicks in you'll be experiencing 30 G's." Yikes! Even Scotty would be impressed!
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: EnumaElish
Noisy Rhysling said:
One good howler right at the start: "When the ion engine kicks in you'll be experiencing 30 G's." Yikes! Even Scotty would be impressed!
Heh. "But don't worry, it'll only be the weight of two mid-sized cars pressing down on the air-filled compressible cavity that -is- was your lungs."
 
DaveC426913 said:
Heh. "But don't worry, it'll only be the weight of two mid-sized cars pressing down on the air-filled compressible cavity that -is- was your lungs."
I just want an ion engine that can kick it at 30 g. from the start up. The Hermes could have been back to Mars in mumble days.
 
  • #10
DaveC426913 said:
In one of Larry Niven's stories, a scientist found a small black hole and started dropping highly ionized material into it until it had built up a significant charge. Then he was able to wield it with a giant electromagnet, and use it as a nasty weapon, swallowing passing ships whole without a trace.
Ha ha ha! They laughed at my theories. Now they tremble before the might of my XO Ray!
 
  • #11
In Thor 2 they seemed to have grenades of a sort that crushed the target down into an infinitesimal point.
 
  • #12
Rubidium_71 said:
In Thor 2 they seemed to have grenades of a sort that crushed the target down into an infinitesimal point.
I was wondering about them. They could be sending the items in the affected area into another space/time?
 
  • #13
In the 2009 Star Trek movie, the renegade Romulan mining vessel from the future has a barrel of something called red matter. If a tiny drop is injected into a planet's core it would cause the planet to implode, very much like creating a black hole at the planet's center.

Incidentally and tangentially, Federation ships are equipped with gravitational sensors, I'm guessing like LIGO turned into a hand-held device. Or a smart phone app.
 
  • #14
Noisy Rhysling said:
I was wondering about them. They could be sending the items in the affected area into another space/time?
The impression I got from the effect they used was that the target was physically crushed rather than transported. Maybe the debris ended up in another dimension? They never really explained the nature of that weapon in detail.
 
  • #15
In Gene Roddenberry's Andromeda, some of the antagonists' ships were armed with "point singularity projectors" that fired tiny black holes at the protagonists' ships.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: ComplexVar89
  • #16
The Bill said:
In Gene Roddenberry's Andromeda, some of the antagonists' ships were armed with "point singularity projectors" that fired tiny black holes at the protagonists' ships.
I just pictured a Yosemite Sam-type character loading a blunderbuss with a mini-black hole and firing it at Bugs' space ship.

I got to lay off the tequila.
 
  • #17
Noisy Rhysling said:
I just pictured a Yosemite Sam-type character loading a blunderbuss with a mini-black hole and firing it at Bugs' space ship.

I got to lay off the tequila.

Well, Andromeda was very much on the "space fantasy" side of the spectrum, so... Basically, your mental picture is more explanatory than the show, since the show wisely didn't even try to explain most of the technology. They mostly took a "yup, this is happening" approach.
 
  • #18
The Bill said:
Well, Andromeda was very much on the "space fantasy" side of the spectrum, so... Basically, your mental picture is more explanatory than the show, since the show wisely didn't even try to explain most of the technology. They mostly took a "yup, this is happening" approach.
"And it came to pass that in the land of Nod a sciency person did discover a new principle. And he looked upon it and it was good."
 
  • #19
Noisy Rhysling said:
I just pictured a Yosemite Sam-type character loading a blunderbuss with a mini-black hole and firing it at Bugs' space ship.

I got to lay off the tequila.
Maybe he could defend himself with this:
ddgun.jpg


Of course, it is just a one-time use weapon.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: jim mcnamara
  • #20
The Bill said:
Well, Andromeda was very much on the "space fantasy" side of the spectrum, so... Basically, your mental picture is more explanatory than the show, since the show wisely didn't even try to explain most of the technology. They mostly took a "yup, this is happening" approach.

Unlike its sister show, Star Trek, which tried to explain the tech and ended coming up with a lot of BS.
 
  • #21
They would have done OK if they hadn't introduced the transporters back in ToS.
Warp drive is explainable. Transporters are beyond even 24th century tech.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • · Replies 124 ·
5
Replies
124
Views
18K
  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
7K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
5K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
2K