Simplifying G1(1+F1)/(1+G1F2(1+F1)) with feedback terms

Join the discussion
Registration is free. Start your own thread to ask a follow-up.
1 reply · 2K views
magnifik
Messages
350
Reaction score
0
I am trying to simply G1 = G1(1+F1) / (1 + G1F2(1+F1)) in terms of G1, G2, H2, and H3 where F1 = G2/(1-G2H2) and F2 = G3 / (1-G3H3)

i got the result
(G1(1-G2H2)(1-G3H3) + G1G2(1-G3H3)) / ((1-G2H2)(1-G3H3) + G1G3(1-G2H2) + G1G2G3)

however, the book gives the result with a +1 in the denominator so their denominator is 1 + (1-G2H2)(1-G3H3) + G1G3(1-G2H2) + G1G2G3

i did the problem 3 times and got the same answer. is the solution in the book a typo, or am i doing something wrong?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
magnifik said:
I am trying to simply G1 = G1(1+F1) / (1 + G1F2(1+F1)) in terms of G1, G2, H2, and H3 where F1 = G2/(1-G2H2) and F2 = G3 / (1-G3H3)

i got the result
(G1(1-G2H2)(1-G3H3) + G1G2(1-G3H3)) / ((1-G2H2)(1-G3H3) + G1G3(1-G2H2) + G1G2G3)

however, the book gives the result with a +1 in the denominator so their denominator is 1 + (1-G2H2)(1-G3H3) + G1G3(1-G2H2) + G1G2G3

i did the problem 3 times and got the same answer. is the solution in the book a typo, or am i doing something wrong?

I used Maple (a computer algebra system) to do the question and got your answer exactly. Either the book is wrong or you copied something incorrectly.

RGV