Solution to the lithium discrepancy

  • Thread starter EL
  • Start date
  • Tags
    Lithium
In summary: Fields: "The recent publication in Nature provides a nice solution to the discrepancy in lithium levels. The linear expanding model, however, also results in an overproduction of lithium which cannot be explained by any mechanisms explored in the pre-1976 days. This includes nucleosynthesis by secondary explosions of super massive objects, nucleosynthesis in inhomogeneous models, the effect of inhomogeneous n/p ratios during the QGP phase transition, and spallation of light nuclei at a later epoch. A combination of inhomogeneous models and spallation may provide the most promising explanation for the observed abundances of light elements."In summary, a recent publication in Nature offers a solution to the discrepancy in lithium levels, but the linear expanding model
  • #1
EL
Science Advisor
558
0
Space news on Phys.org
  • #2
Note the linear expanding model also overproduces Lithium.

Nucleosynthesis in a Simmering Universe
To get the observed abundances of light elements besides 4He, one would have to fall back upon a host of other mechanisms that were being explored in the SBB in the pre-1976 days. The most popular processes are:
(i) nucleosynthesis by secondary explosions of super massive objects [6], (ii) nucleosynthesis in inhomogeneous models,
(iii) effect of inhomogeneous n/p ratios as the universe comes out of the QGP phase transition,
(iv) spallation of light nuclei at a much later epoch. It is easy to rule out the survival of D by the processes (ii) and (iii) while the process (i) requires very special initial conditions.
It also shares a common difficulty with process (iv), viz.: the production of D to the required levels is possible but it is accompanied by an overproduction of lithium. Any later destruction of lithium in turn completely destroys D. Within the framework of the cosmological evolution that we are exploring here, we find the best promise in a model that
would combine (ii) and (iv).
(Pages 7 & 8)

Garth
 

What is the "Solution to the lithium discrepancy"?

The "Solution to the lithium discrepancy" refers to a long-standing problem in astrophysics where the observed abundance of lithium in the universe is significantly lower than what is predicted by theoretical models.

Why is the lithium discrepancy important?

The lithium discrepancy is important because it challenges our current understanding of the formation and evolution of the universe. It also has implications for our understanding of the structure of stars and the processes that occur within them.

What are some proposed solutions to the lithium discrepancy?

There are several proposed solutions to the lithium discrepancy, including the possibility of incomplete mixing of stellar material, the existence of unknown nuclear reactions, and the effects of galactic chemical evolution.

What evidence supports these proposed solutions?

Scientists have conducted various observations and experiments to support these proposed solutions. For example, observations of the surface abundance of lithium in old stars suggest that incomplete mixing may be a contributing factor, while experiments at particle accelerators have provided evidence for possible unknown nuclear reactions.

Is the lithium discrepancy completely solved?

No, the lithium discrepancy is not completely solved. While there are promising explanations, further research and observations are needed to fully understand and resolve this discrepancy.

Similar threads

Replies
15
Views
5K
Replies
7
Views
1K
Replies
15
Views
2K
Replies
1
Views
918
Replies
8
Views
872
Replies
1
Views
1K
Replies
1
Views
911
Replies
1
Views
1K
Replies
5
Views
1K
Replies
0
Views
392
Back
Top