zoobyshoe
- 6,506
- 1,268
There never was a catch. There is an ambiguity. You could assume, as you did, that they were required to pay customs duty on the whole amount they originally wanted to take into Paris, (even though they wouldn't actually be taking that amount in because they were using part of it to pay the duty) or, you could assume they would only be required to pay duty on the amount they actually ended up taking in, 59 and 18 barrels, respectively.zoki85 said:That doesn't interest me anymore now if you confirm this way that was the catch;)
The problem is that either way, the amount they end up paying, and the number of barrels they end up taking into Paris, are exactly the same, despite the fact the price per barrel and the duty amount charged per barrel are different in the two different scenarios. The puzzle, as its stated (and I copied it verbatim from the book) has no indication of which of these two possibilities it is looking for. It makes a difference because they specifically ask for the price per barrel and the amount of duty.
I didn't see any way around it but to calculate both possibilities and then check to see which the book wanted.