Solve Equation II: $(1+a!)(1+b!)=(a+b)!$

  • Context:
  • Thread starter Thread starter anemone
  • Start date Start date
Join the discussion
Registration is free. Ask a follow-up in this thread, or start your own.
2 replies · 2K views
anemone
Gold Member
MHB
POTW Director
Messages
3,851
Reaction score
115
Solve in non-negative integers the equation $(1+a!)(1+b!)=(a+b)!$.
 
Mathematics news on Phys.org
anemone said:
Solve in non-negative integers the equation $(1+a!)(1+b!)=(a+b)!$.

Hello.

[tex](1+a!)(1+b!)=1+a!+a!b!+b!=(a+b)![/tex]

[tex]If \ a>b \rightarrow{}b!|(a!,a!b!,(a+b)!)[/tex]

Therefore:

[tex]b!|1 \rightarrow{}b!=1 \rightarrow{}b=0 \ or \ b=1[/tex]

[tex]If \ b=1 \rightarrow{}(1+a!)2=(a+1)![/tex]

[tex]2+2a!=(a+1)a! \rightarrow{}a=2[/tex]

[tex]If \ b=0 \rightarrow{}(1+a!)2=a![/tex]

[tex]a!=-2 \ absurdity[/tex]

The end:

[tex]If \ a=b \rightarrow{}(1+a!)(1+a!)=1+2a!+a!a!=(2a)![/tex]

[tex]a!|1 \rightarrow{}a=0 \ or \ a=1[/tex]

[tex]If \ a=0 \rightarrow{}2*2=1 \ absurdity[/tex]

[tex]If \ a=1 \rightarrow{}2*2=2 \ absurdity[/tex]

I will conclude by:

[tex]If \ a>b \rightarrow{}a=2 \ and \ b=1[/tex]

Same b>a ...

Regards.
 
Last edited:
mente oscura said:
Hello.

[tex](1+a!)(1+b!)=1+a!+a!b!+b!=(a+b)![/tex]

[tex]If \ a>b \rightarrow{}b!|(a!,a!b!,(a+b)!)[/tex]

Therefore:

[tex]b!|1 \rightarrow{}b!=1 \rightarrow{}b=0 \ or \ b=1[/tex]

[tex]If \ b=1 \rightarrow{}(1+a!)2=(a+1)![/tex]

[tex]2+2a!=(a+1)a! \rightarrow{}a=2[/tex]

[tex]If \ b=0 \rightarrow{}(1+a!)2=a![/tex]

[tex]a!=-2 \ absurdity[/tex]

The end:

[tex]If \ a=b \rightarrow{}(1+a!)(1+a!)=1+2a!+a!a!=(2a)![/tex]

[tex]a!|1 \rightarrow{}a=0 \ or \ a=1[/tex]

[tex]If \ a=0 \rightarrow{}2*2=1 \ absurdity[/tex]

[tex]If \ a=1 \rightarrow{}2*2=2 \ absurdity[/tex]

I will conclude by:

[tex]If \ a>b \rightarrow{}a=2 \ and \ b=1[/tex]

Same b>a ...

Regards.

Well done, mente oscura! Thanks for participating too!