Discussion Overview
The discussion revolves around the search for a specific quotation related to the nature of scientific progress and the resistance to new theories by established scientists. Participants explore the origins of the quote and its implications for the philosophy of science.
Discussion Character
- Exploratory
- Conceptual clarification
Main Points Raised
- One participant paraphrases a quote about how old scientists resist radical new theories until they are replaced by new generations.
- Another participant suggests that the idea aligns with Thomas Kuhn's theory regarding stability and revolution in science.
- A different participant attributes the quote to Max Planck, providing a more complete version that emphasizes the gradual acceptance of new ideas as older scientists die out.
- Another participant shares a personal version of the sentiment, stating that "science progresses one death at a time."
- A participant recommends a website for finding quotes related to scientists, sharing a quote from Faraday as an example.
Areas of Agreement / Disagreement
Participants generally agree on the attribution of the quote to Max Planck, but there is some uncertainty regarding the exact wording and the connection to Thomas Kuhn's theories. The discussion does not reach a definitive consensus on the original source or the implications of the quote.
Contextual Notes
There are variations in the wording of the quote discussed, and participants note the importance of specific terms like "rarely" versus "never." The discussion also reflects differing interpretations of the implications of the quote for the philosophy of science.
Who May Find This Useful
This discussion may be of interest to those studying the philosophy of science, the history of scientific thought, or individuals looking for insights into the dynamics of scientific progress and resistance to change.