Tangherlini transformations and absolute simultaneity: a rotor model

  • Level: High School 
  • Thread starter AlexOsipovich
  • Start date
0 replies · 11 views
AlexOsipovich
Messages
10
Reaction score
2
TL;DR
Comparing rotating rotor kinematics via Tangherlini transforms (absolute simultaneity, 1958) and standard STR.
To be clear on the framework: I am using the transformations introduced by F. R. Tangherlini in his 1958 PhD dissertation (dissertation), specifically the framework detailed in Chapter 3: 'Velocity of light and synchronization of clocks under the Absolute Lorentz Transformation'. In this framework, absolute simultaneity is preserved, and the one-way velocity of light becomes anisotropic while the out-and-back speed remains invariant. The goal is to see how this kinematical choice affects the coordinate time of a rotating rotor in the absolute frame.

I have made some adjustments to the model and would appreciate your input on the symmetry of its half-turns.

The Setup:
• A laboratory moves through the AFR at a constant velocity V = 370 km/s along the X-axis.
• Inside the lab, a rotor of radius R = 1 m spins uniformly with a tangential speed u = 600 m/s.
• Two stationary triggers (Sensor 1 and Sensor 2) are placed on the stator diametrically opposite each other along the X-axis.
• Two clocks (Clock A and Clock B) are mounted on the rotor rim 180° apart:
• Clock A runs only during the first half-turn (from Sensor 1 to Sensor 2, moving against the V direction).
• Clock B runs only during the second half-turn (from Sensor 2 back to Sensor 1, moving along the V direction).

My Question:
Could you please clarify whether the half-turns of the rotor will be equal in duration according to AFR coordinate time, if calculated using Tangherlini transformations?

My preliminary calculations show a stark contrast: in Tangherlini's framework (absolute simultaneity), the sensors trigger simultaneously and coordinate time is symmetric, yet proper time differs. In standard STR (relativity of simultaneity), the sensors trigger at different times, exactly compensating the time dilation to yield zero proper time difference.

I have a Python simulation and mathematical derivation for both cases. I can share the full code or equations in this thread if you are interested in reviewing the math. I'm looking forward to your feedback on the conceptual differences.