The Perils of Quantum Cryptography?

  • Thread starter Dr Wu
  • Start date
In summary, the conversation discusses a suggestion to ban quantum-based communication systems across social media platforms due to concerns about criminality and social instability. The ban is compared to the 1963 Nuclear Test Ban Treaty and is seen as a potential solution to prevent widespread civil anarchy in the future. However, it is acknowledged that enforcing such a ban may be difficult and could potentially lead to the end of intelligence-gathering agencies like the NSA. The conversation also touches on the issue of government oversight of private communications and the impact of advancing technology on enforcement measures.
  • #1
Dr Wu
A suggestion for a short story or film script: governments around the world, concerned about the rise of criminality and social instability as a result of quantum supremacy, promptly ban all quantum-based communication systems across the social media landscape: in short usher in the equivalent of the 1963 Nuclear Test Ban Treaty, but for QS.

The underlying premise behind such a moratorium is that QS-based communications - viewed here as a kind of truly impenetrable Dark Web - would plunge human civilisation back to how it was before the invention of the telegraph. . . with all its implications intact. Of course, it could be argued that QS is needed precisely to protect individuals from governmental snooping.

That's not the premise here, though. Rather, it's an attempt to foresee how future developments in both AI and quantum computing could create the conditions for distilling widespread civil anarchy in the not-too-distant future. Slightly histrionic, perhaps. But this is SF, after all, and not all SF gets it wrong.

Any thoughts?
Last edited by a moderator:
Physics news on
  • #2
It's tough to forbid a specific technology indefinitely. As technology improves and becomes easily available, it usually favors the creation and used of weapons, communication, etc over the enforcement measures.
In the case of private communications, I do not favor a government-citizen relationship where government is overseeing citizen communications.
  • Like
Likes BillTre
  • #3
Yes, I suspect it will be impossible to enforce such a global ban given the seemingly unstoppable march of technology. If so, it must surely spell the end for intelligence-gathering agencies like the NSA, although old-fashioned bugging methods and similar forms of surveillance could still continue to exist perhaps. Strange, all the same.

Similar threads

  • Science Fiction and Fantasy Media
  • Special and General Relativity