The Space Tent: A Revolutionary Idea for Structuring Martian Towns

  • Context: Undergrad 
  • Thread starter Thread starter Protonic
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Idea Space
Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the concept of constructing Martian towns using a proposed structure called "The Space Tent," which is envisioned as an inflatable dome made from a superstrong plastic. Participants explore the feasibility, structural integrity, and protective capabilities of this idea in the context of Martian conditions, as well as comparisons to traditional glass domes.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Debate/contested
  • Technical explanation

Main Points Raised

  • One participant argues that traditional glass domes are structurally unsound and proposes an inflatable plastic dome as a safer alternative.
  • Another participant suggests that using thicker, solid panels shaped like a dome could provide better structure and rigidity than a simple inflatable design.
  • A participant questions the assumption that asteroids would bounce off the structure, emphasizing the high impact speeds of asteroids and the need for more robust engineering solutions.
  • Some participants note that the design is intended for Mars, where the atmosphere may provide some protection against smaller asteroids, unlike the Moon.
  • There is a discussion about the potential for using materials that are easy to patch or self-sealing, with a mention of nanotechnology enabling self-repairing plastics.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express differing views on the structural integrity and protective capabilities of the proposed inflatable dome compared to traditional materials. There is no consensus on the best approach or material for constructing habitats on Mars, and the discussion remains unresolved regarding the effectiveness of the proposed ideas.

Contextual Notes

Participants highlight various assumptions about the impact of asteroids and the atmospheric conditions on Mars, as well as the limitations of current materials in withstanding such impacts. The discussion reflects a range of perspectives on engineering challenges without resolving the technical uncertainties involved.

Who May Find This Useful

This discussion may be of interest to those exploring innovative architectural solutions for extraterrestrial habitats, as well as individuals interested in the engineering challenges associated with building on Mars.

Protonic
Messages
8
Reaction score
0
Hey we've all seen those movies and documentaries where civilization has buil giant glass domes on The Moon or oher planets. I say this is structurally unsound. It's going to break or atleast crack. I divised an idea called The Space Tent. We take a giant plastic bag the size of our martian township. We inflate it so it is a giant dome. It's infalted high so large car sized asteroids and objects will bounce off. It's smaller ones that I think are going to be the problem.

My Physics tells me that if we make it out off a superstrong form of plastic it may work. 2 actually. 1 innnerlayer that can stretch lik a garbage bag when large objects hit it. And then an outerlayer of tough tight plastic that will stop small sharp slow objects from peircing it. The logic is hat large object would be slown down and just roll off. Light objects would just bounce off. Least the fast one. The slow ones might get stuck on he plastic.

Then there's of course the issue of how do we repair it when there's a hole. I hink this beter than glass cause it would certainly break on contact. We'd have to make giant pillar cause glass is heavy. It would also be a lot more expensive. It may work cause they use this on this space station I believe. I wouldn't use it on The Moon cause there's no atmosphere to stop really large asteroids.
 
Astronomy news on Phys.org
Why do you assume they are glass? Surely if we have a super strong plastic, strong enough that we can inflate to do the job and protect us inside, it would make sense to make thicker (more solid) layers and create panels in the shape of a dome. Giving you better structure and rigidity. Plus, far more protection. Kevlar body armour style.
 
Do you have any clue how fast asteroids hit the moon? Nothing we can make will cause them to 'bounce off'. You need to learn a lot more about physics and engineering...
 
That's why I sai I wouldn't make it on The Moon. It has no atmosphere. This would be for Mars and thick atmosphered planets. Besides hey use an airbag on The Space Station.
 
Protonic said:
That's why I sai I wouldn't make it on The Moon. It has no atmosphere. This would be for Mars and thick atmosphered planets. Besides hey use an airbag on The Space Station.

You've seen the craters on Mars right? And you know the atmospheric build up of the planet?
 
Yes Mars is 1/3 the size of Earth/ I know he atmosphere is far thinner but it could deflect and bun small asteroids. Besides if any asteroid large enough to make huge craes hit our colony it wouldn't matte if the cover was made of glass or plastic.
 
Protonic said:
Yes Mars is 1/3 the size of Earth/ I know he atmosphere is far thinner but it could deflect and bun small asteroids. Besides if any asteroid large enough to make huge craes hit our colony it wouldn't matte if the cover was made of glass or plastic.
...or several feet of steel reinforced concrete, for that matter. So the dome doesn't have to be made to withstand such things.

Why not just make it from a material easy to patch (or even self-sealing?)?
 
With nanotechnology doesn't someone have selfrepairing plastic?