Topsy Turvy™ Upside-down Tomato Planter

  • Thread starter Thread starter Ivan Seeking
  • Start date Start date
Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the Topsy Turvy™ upside-down tomato planter, exploring its effectiveness and practicality for growing tomatoes and potentially other vegetables. Participants share their experiences, opinions, and concerns regarding the claims made about the planter's design and functionality.

Discussion Character

  • Debate/contested
  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Personal experience

Main Points Raised

  • Some participants express skepticism about the claims that inverting the plant enhances water and nutrient flow, suggesting that this contradicts established plant biology.
  • Others note that the design may help avoid ground-related issues like fungus and rot, but question whether it provides any real advantage over traditional planting methods.
  • One participant recounts a negative experience with the planter, describing issues with water pooling and plant health, leading to the plant's demise.
  • Another participant shares a successful gardening technique involving training plants to grow along a fence for better sunlight exposure, contrasting it with the upside-down method.
  • Some participants discuss the potential for using the planter with other vegetables, with one specifically cautioning against using it for peppers due to sunlight requirements.
  • Concerns are raised about the planter's safety, with reports of it being recalled due to structural issues.
  • Several participants share humorous or critical reflections on the concept of growing plants upside down, questioning its practicality.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants generally do not reach consensus on the effectiveness of the Topsy Turvy planter. While some share positive anecdotes, others report significant problems and express skepticism about the underlying claims of the product.

Contextual Notes

Participants highlight various assumptions about plant biology and environmental conditions that may affect the planter's performance. There are also references to anecdotal experiences that may not be universally applicable.

Who May Find This Useful

Gardeners, horticulturists, and individuals interested in innovative planting techniques may find this discussion relevant, particularly those considering unconventional gardening methods.

  • #31
Evo said:
You should post in the food and gardening threads.

Oooh, I didn't know they existed yet! Talk about a diverse forum: I'm in!

P.S. Ahhh threads, not a sub forum. How about "cooking and gardening" under Chemistry? :smile:

Argentum Vulpes: HA! So true about the watering. 3 gallons, maybe it comes with 20 of those of "watering bulbs"? :biggrin:
 
Last edited:
Biology news on Phys.org
  • #32
We have a hose on our back deck. It only takes a few minutes a day to give the tomatoes and herbs and flowers a drink.
 
  • #33
turbo-1 said:
We have a hose on our back deck. It only takes a few minutes a day to give the tomatoes and herbs and flowers a drink.

You lucky devil. That's a great system... any pics?
 
  • #34
I have limited full-sun planting space at my home so bought one of these monstrosities. Total failure. Bought all the suggested nutrients and followed all the tips and directions. But, as previously noted by someone else who was taken in by these seat-holes, the water/mud drains out the bottom, full of the proscribed soil and nutrients, drools down the stem of the poor struggling upside-down plant and rots all the leaves and stalks. We tried to salvage the project after giving it a good 2 weeks to revert to some sort of success - we poked some additional holes in the sides of the bag in hopes the muddy water would drain somewhere other than all over the plant, but no luck. What a maddening waste of time, money, and plant life. Sheesh. Sorry to anyone else who tried this but glad to know I'm not the only one to get suckered in.
 
  • #35
Just found this thread. Wife found these at Bed Bath & B. We have never had much luck with tomatoes. We get lots of cherry tomatoes but have never had any luck with a slicing tomato. We just can't do any worse. Here are some pics of what we have now:

Jun10038-1.jpg


Jun10043.jpg


Jun10041.jpg


Jun10040.jpg


I am on the opposite end of tomato growing scale from the other posters in this thread, a complete incompetent. If these things can put some tomatoes on my table I will be as happy a lark.
 
  • #36
WOW. How did you DO that? Our tomato plant just rotted away in the topsy-turvy! I am very interested in more details. How big were the plants when you planted them and are they still doing this splendidly?! More details; please!
 
  • #37
We used a commercial potting soil, the plants were in 3" pots and about 4-6in tall when planted. We killed a plant when I shoved the roots through the hole. My wife tried again by threading the plant through the hole.

Why we aren't rotting off stems?? I don't know, we had some water dripping through initially, which seems to have stopped now. It has been cool and rainy since we planted them. For the most part we have let the rain water them, but now the weatherman tells me we have some sun ahead of us. Today was the first full sun since I don't know when. Now we need to figure out how much water they will need. Seems that too much water would lead to what you describe, I will keep a close eye on these and post more pics.

My wife bought a pack of 6 plants, I killed one stuffing it into the TT, the other 3 have been stuck into the ground, they are doing ok, but not nearly as well as the 2 in the TT.

It's too late to get any pics tonight, I will get some tomorrow. The last pics were taken on 5 Jun. I have pic from the day we planted, 5 May, but Photobucket doesn't want me on tonight, so will try again tomorrow.
 
  • #38
P7301613_resize.jpg


P7301614_resize.jpg


Both started as 2 inch seedlings, we'll be getting our second harvest. Standard potting soil.
 
  • #39
Either of you gotten any tomatoes? If so, how many? I've already gotten a few pounds off of a tomato planted in a pot on my patio and my neighbor has gotten zero off of their TT plant. My plant is at least 5 times the size of hers.
 
  • #40
I HAD eleven plants. I got maybe a bushel of fruit before they died from some sort of fungus. Actually, I'm having a bacon and tomato sandwich right now. hmmmm.
 
  • #41
dlgoff said:
I HAD eleven plants. I got maybe a bushel of fruit before they died from some sort of fungus. Actually, I'm having a bacon and tomato sandwich right now. hmmmm.
Sorry to hear that dl.
 
  • #42
I've gotten nearly 10 pounds off of the Early girls and I'm thinking we're going to at least triple that going out, still waiting on the Champions (we planted quite late).
 
  • #43
jekostas said:
I've gotten nearly 10 pounds off of the Early girls and I'm thinking we're going to at least triple that going out, still waiting on the Champions (we planted quite late).
How many plants do you have? A plant as small as the ones you posted couldn't produce much. ? I've been picking the cherry tomatoes for about a month (greenhouse plants) and they're about 6' tall! The larger tomatoes are just starting to ripen. I've only been doing container planting for 3 years since I moved out of my house, but the yield is definitely limited by the container size.
 
Last edited:
  • #44
Evo said:
How many plants do you have? A plant as small as the ones you posted couldn't produce much. ? I've been picking the cherry tomatoes for about a month (greenhouse plants) but the larger tomatoes are just starting to ripen.

We have four plants - two Early Girls and two Champions. One of each at our apartment, and one of each at my parents' house (where the rest of our garden resides). We didn't have any more room on our balcony.

The Early girls have been quite prolific so far, but the fruit has been somewhat undersized.

As to the size, well, they aren't small. We've been constantly pruning back non-fruit bearing branches over the last month or so as to not overload the main stems (we don't have supports for them).
 
  • #45
jekostas said:
We have four plants - two Early Girls and two Champions. One of each at our apartment, and one of each at my parents' house (where the rest of our garden resides). We didn't have any more room on our balcony.

The Early girls have been quite prolific so far, but the fruit has been somewhat undersized.

As to the size, well, they aren't small. We've been constantly pruning back non-fruit bearing branches over the last month or so as to not overload the main stems (we don't have supports for them).
I'm finding that my tomatoes are undersized also, i read that they shouldn't be planted an anything less than a 5 gallon container, which is pretty big.

These is one of the cherry tomato plants a week ago, after being picked, they're tasty, but small and the skins are tough.

017ln.jpg


You should join our gardening thread https://www.physicsforums.com/showthread.php?t=74652&page=151

I am the lone container gardener there, I could use some moral support.
 

Similar threads

Growing tomatoes upside down and gravitropism
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
5K