Volume of revolution: why does my answer differ from the key?

10 replies · 2K views · last reply
delsoo
Messages
97
Reaction score
0
Exam question text: Sketch the graph of y = 1 + 1/(4x^2 + 1) with a labelled diagram [2 marks]. Region R is bounded by this curve, the axes and x = 1/2. Using 2x = tan θ, find (a) the area of R [5], (b) the volume when R is rotated about the x-axis [8].


Handwritten working for problem 7: a sketch of a bell-shaped curve with a shaded region up to x = 0.5, followed by the derivative of y = 1 + 1/(4x^2+1), the integral of y dx from 0 to 0.5 with substitution 2x = tan θ, and the final area R = (1/8)(4 + π).


https://www.physicsforums.com/attachments/69284

Homework Statement



i have done the part a, for b , i use the key in the (circled part equation ) into calculator .. my ans is also different form the ans given. is my concept correct by the way?

Homework Equations





The Attempt at a Solution

 
Attachments
  • Handwritten working for part b of a volume of revolution problem: v = integral of y squared dv, rewritten with y = 1 + 1/(4x^2+1) and integrated from 0 to 0.5, with the first line circled in red.
    DSC_0140~2.jpg
    43.4 KB · Views: 501
Last edited:
One obvious point is that you are missing a factor of "[itex]\pi[/itex]". The area of a circle is [itex]\pi r^2= \pi y^2[/itex].
 
after adding pi, my ans is 2.80... the ans is 5.047746784, which part is wrong?
 
It would be a good idea here to use vertical line segments, otherwise you're going to have to set up multiple integrals. So leave everything as ##y(x)##, then:

##r_{in} = 0##
##r_{out} = 1 + \frac{1}{4x^2 + 1}##
##height = dx##

##dV = 2\pi(\frac{r_{in} + r_{out}}{2})(r_{out} - r_{in})(height)##

Integrating the volume element should give you the answer you want.
 
delsoo said:
after adding pi, my ans is 2.80... the ans is 5.047746784, which part is wrong?

delsoo, your method is fine and I seem to get the same definite integral as you (which gives the correct answer too). The definite integral you have to evaluate is:

$$\pi\int_0^{1/2} \left(1+\frac{1}{4x^2+1}\right)^2\,dx$$

If you drop the factor of ##\pi##, you should get 1.60675.

Use the substitution ##2x=\tan\theta## to make things easier.
 
Pranav-Arora said:
delsoo, your method is fine and I seem to get the same definite integral as you (which gives the correct answer too). The definite integral you have to evaluate is:

$$\pi\int_0^{1/2} \left(1+\frac{1}{4x^2+1}\right)^2\,dx$$

If you drop the factor of ##\pi##, you should get 1.60675.

Erm this is misleading.

The answer is indeed 5.04775 complements of wolfram:

http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=integrate+2pi%28+%281%2B+1%2F%284x^2%2B1%29%29%2F2+%29%281%2B+1%2F%284x^2%2B1%29%29+from+0+to+1%2F2
 
Zondrina said:
Erm this is misleading.

Can you please explain to me how my statements are misleading? :)
 
Pranav-Arora said:
Can you please explain to me how my statements are misleading? :)

Your integrand is fine, it's just the answer you got I was worried about.
 
Zondrina said:
Your integrand is fine, it's just the answer you got I was worried about.

I must be missing something but what is the problem with the answer I wrote? Are you talking about "1.60675"? :confused:
 
Pranav-Arora said:
I must be missing something but what is the problem with the answer I wrote? Are you talking about "1.60675"? :confused:

Yeah I wasn't sure why you wrote that.
 
Zondrina said:
Yeah I wasn't sure why you wrote that.

Ah, I think I worded it poorly. What I meant was this:
$$\int_0^1 \left(1+\frac{1}{4x^2+1}\right)^2\,dx=1.60675$$
And I feel delsoo did some mistake while evaluating the above definite integral.