Wanted: complete errata sheet for quantum mechanics demystified

In summary: I just bought the book with enthusiasm to begin to understand the mechanics of the quantum world. I have to say that for and outsider (i am a computer engineer with no quantum related physics background) the book is rather good. It is giving different examples. If you are a physicst or in a more related area the book might be too simple for you. But I liked it. The only bad thing about the book is the famous errors. For a self study man like me, it is crucial to know if i did it wrong or right and I can't be sure of that for this book.. other than that i like this kind of books
  • #1
lolgarithms
120
0
yo.

today I got "quantum mechanics demystified", and I heard it has a lot of typos. Can you list them all for me (in tex if possible)?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #3
the author's errata sheet doens't list all the typos.

can someone please find ALL of them?
 
  • #4
working on it captain
 
  • #5
Is that a good book? Just wondering, might buy it.
 
  • #6
it has so many ****in mistakes. sumtimes whole pages are replete w/ typos.
 
  • #7
lolgarithms said:
the author's errata sheet doens't list all the typos.

can someone please find ALL of them?
The book has much deeper problems than the typos. Even his definition of a group is wrong.
 
  • #8
I would not recommend this book.
 
  • #9
Doc Al said:
I would not recommend this book.

Doc, I was just wondering..whats your opinion of the QFT demystified book?
 
  • #10
maverick280857 said:
Doc, I was just wondering..whats your opinion of the QFT demystified book?
Sadly, what little QFT knowledge I once had has atrophied long ago, so I cannot give an informed opinion. :frown: But I did give that book a look, and own several of his others (including the quantum and relativity ones); I do not care for any of them. (Which is not to say that some good stuff cannot be gleaned from them, numerous mistakes notwithstanding, if you know where to look. Nonetheless, I'd give them a pass.)
 
  • #11
maverick280857 said:
Doc, I was just wondering..whats your opinion of the QFT demystified book?

We have some old threads about that particular book.

MY opinion is that it COULD be good if there were less typos and better organized, e.g. sometimes he just repeats the definition of things on the very next page, and refer reader to wrong chapters.

It contains some good stuff although, but I one has to know the stuff before I guess, otherwise one will not get far with all the typos etc.
 
  • #12
From reading the Amazon reviews, it's not just the density of typos that's the problem with the QFT book, it's that he makes many flat out wrong statements about the physics.

On a subject I'm more familiar with, I can't imagine anyone being "demystified" by his relativity book. It's just an info dump.

As for a good, cheap QM book, maybe the book by Park that has been reprinted by Dover.
 
Last edited:
  • #13
[quote="jimmysnyder]The book has much deeper problems than the typos. Even his definition of a group is wrong. [/quote]
Where does he give the definition of the group? What is the correct definition? I wanted all the errors, not just the typoes.

No wonder everyone hates demystified books. I have a lot of them because they sell them at Barnes &Noble.

What are you guys' opinions on the string theory demystified book?
 
  • #14
lolgarithms said:
Where does he give the definition of the group? What is the correct definition?

No wonder everyone hates demystified books. I have a lot of them because they sell them at Barnes &Noble.

What are you guys' opinions on the string theory demystified book?

Page 50

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Group_(mathematics)#Definition

Have not studying it, A First Course in String Theory is the best intro text
 
  • #15
guys guys guys. i bought the book with enthusiasm to begin to understand the mechanics of the quantum world. i have to say that for and outsider (i am a computer engineer with no quantum related physics background) the book is rather good. it is giving different examples. if you are a physicst or in a more related area the book might be too simple for you. but i liked it. the only bad thing about the book is the famous errors. for a self study man like me, it is crucial to know if i did it wrong or right and i can't be sure of that for this book.. other than that i like this kind of books ...
 

1. What is a complete errata sheet for quantum mechanics demystified?

A complete errata sheet for quantum mechanics demystified is a list of corrections and updates to the book "Quantum Mechanics Demystified." It is used to address any errors or mistakes that may have been found in the book since its publication. This ensures that readers have the most accurate and up-to-date information.

2. Why is a complete errata sheet necessary for a book on quantum mechanics?

Quantum mechanics is a complex and constantly evolving field of study. As new research and discoveries are made, it is common for books on the subject to contain errors or outdated information. A complete errata sheet is necessary to ensure that readers have the most accurate and current understanding of quantum mechanics.

3. How can I obtain a complete errata sheet for quantum mechanics demystified?

A complete errata sheet for quantum mechanics demystified can typically be found on the publisher's website or the author's website. It may also be included in newer editions of the book. If you are unable to find it online, you can contact the publisher or author directly to request a copy.

4. What types of errors can be found in a complete errata sheet for quantum mechanics demystified?

The most common types of errors found in a complete errata sheet for quantum mechanics demystified include mathematical mistakes, typographical errors, and outdated information. It may also include clarifications or additional explanations for certain concepts.

5. Is it necessary to review the complete errata sheet before reading "Quantum Mechanics Demystified"?

While it is not necessary to review the complete errata sheet before reading the book, it can be helpful in understanding any potential errors or updates that may affect your understanding of the material. It is recommended to at least review the errata sheet after finishing the book to ensure you have the most accurate understanding of quantum mechanics.

Similar threads

  • Science and Math Textbooks
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • Science and Math Textbooks
Replies
17
Views
1K
  • Science and Math Textbooks
Replies
14
Views
2K
  • Science and Math Textbooks
Replies
13
Views
2K
  • Science and Math Textbooks
Replies
4
Views
1K
  • Science and Math Textbooks
Replies
8
Views
2K
  • Science and Math Textbooks
Replies
6
Views
6K
Replies
5
Views
1K
  • Quantum Interpretations and Foundations
Replies
29
Views
963
  • Science and Math Textbooks
Replies
5
Views
785
Back
Top