Weak interactions: I know why they're weak, but why are they slow?

Join the discussion
Ask a follow-up here, or get your own question answered by working scientists, mathematicians and engineers — people, not an autocomplete.
Real named experts · corrections over time · the nuance an AI answer skips
3 replies · 2K views
nonequilibrium
Messages
1,412
Reaction score
2
Compared to, for example, electromagnetic interactions.

Are the "weakness" and "slowness" perhaps somehow related? Perhaps both "weakness" and "slowness" can both be reformulated as "having a low probability of occurring", making the "slowness" apparent, and making the "weakness" a time-averaged result.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
See e.g. the Fermi rule: The probability PER UNIT TIME of decay is proportional to the square of the coupling constant.

By the way, it is quite frustrating to see that most textbooks on quantum mechanics or quantum field theory do not contain a convincing derivation of the Fermi rule and exponential decay law. One of the rare textbooks that does contain a convincing derivation is the old textbook by E. Merzbacher (1961).
 
Last edited:
We know Weak interactions are weak because of their low probability of happening at all but when they do happen they also take their time about it - about 10-6s.

It is my understanding that these are different properties and the fundamental forces are like that because that is how they are.
Now watch someone correct me :)
 
most textbooks on quantum mechanics or quantum field theory do not contain a convincing derivation of the Fermi rule and exponential decay law.
Messiah Chap XVII beats it to death. But actually Schiff I think has the clearest treatment. He points out that Fermi originally called it "Golden Rule #2". (Rule #1 was the second order perturbation formula.)
It is my understanding that these are different properties and the fundamental forces are like that because that is how they are.
Now watch someone correct me :)
Ok, sure! :smile: Weak interactions are not intrinsically slow. Neutrino events in OPERA, for example, are rare but not slow. Also the weak coupling constant g is not that much smaller. The reason weak decays have a longer lifetime is kinematical: the heavy mass of the W.