What do you consider to be the most interesting alien race?

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion centers around participants' opinions on the most interesting alien races from various science fiction works. The scope includes literary analysis, character exploration, and personal preferences regarding fictional extraterrestrial beings.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Debate/contested

Main Points Raised

  • Some participants express admiration for the Moties from "The Mote in God's Eye," highlighting their societal structure and fatalistic beliefs.
  • Others mention the Kzin as notable for their poor diplomatic skills.
  • One participant introduces the concept of women as an interesting alien race, alongside various alien species from Niven's works, such as the Puppeteers and the Outies.
  • The xenomorphs from the "Alien" franchise are discussed for their unique biological traits and survival capabilities.
  • The Q continuum from "Star Trek" is noted for its ability to change forms and its philosophical implications.
  • Participants mention the First Ones from "Babylon 5," particularly the Vorlons and Shadows, as intriguing due to their mysterious nature.
  • The Fithp from "Footfall" are described as an interesting race with a unique evolutionary background.
  • Some participants reflect on non-humanoid aliens, such as the Na'ka'leen Feeder and the Mi-Go from Lovecraftian lore.
  • Discussion includes references to Hal Clement's works, with mentions of alien races that defy typical biological norms, such as those living on neutron stars.
  • One participant expresses a fondness for the Zerg from "Starcraft," emphasizing their collective consciousness.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants present a variety of opinions on what constitutes the most interesting alien race, with no consensus reached. Multiple competing views remain throughout the discussion.

Contextual Notes

Some references to specific alien characteristics and narratives may depend on individual interpretations of the source material. The discussion includes speculative elements and personal preferences that are not universally agreed upon.

  • #61
Noisy Rhysling said:
Interesting PITAs.
What does "PITAs" mean?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #62
GW150914 said:
What does "PITAs" mean?
Pain In The A..

Urbandictionary is a handy tab for me.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Stephanus
  • #63
GW150914 said:
Q

Q was one of many reasons why I didn't get into STTNG. Omnipotent beings who seem to have nothing better to do with their time than test the rats to see it they live up to their moral standards...let me add a new acronym to this discussion: BTCOOM: bores the crap out of me. Roddenberry had this unending fascination with the question of whether the rest of us could live up to his moral standards. If you shared those moral standards I suppose the question seems only reasonable. If you don't share those moral standards, if you are off by even a fraction of a percent, it seems presumptuous. I never cared much for the feeling that I was being preached to for what everyone assumed--and no one asked me about--was my own good.
 
  • #64
Khatti said:
Q was one of many reasons why I didn't get into STTNG. Omnipotent beings who seem to have nothing better to do with their time than test the rats to see it they live up to their moral standards...let me add a new acronym to this discussion: BTCOOM: bores the crap out of me. Roddenberry had this unending fascination with the question of whether the rest of us could live up to his moral standards. If you shared those moral standards I suppose the question seems only reasonable. If you don't share those moral standards, if you are off by even a fraction of a percent, it seems presumptuous. I never cared much for the feeling that I was being preached to for what everyone assumed--and no one asked me about--was my own good.
The last TOS I watched had Frank Gorshin as a White-On-The-Right/Black-On-The-Left who was oppressing Black-On-The-Right/White-On-The-Left people. It was as clumsy a social commentary as I had seen in my 17 years.
 
  • #65
Noisy Rhysling said:
The last TOS I watched had Frank Gorshin as a White-On-The-Right/Black-On-The-Left who was oppressing Black-On-The-Right/White-On-The-Left people. It was as clumsy a social commentary as I had seen in my 17 years.

Sincerity was supposed to make up for a lot in those days.

Khatti said:
Omnipotent beings who seem to have nothing better to do with their time than test the rats to see it they live up to their moral standards...let me add a new acronym to this discussion: BTCOOM: bores the crap out of me

The thing about writing about the Devil is that I want to see how the Devil's self-interest is served. Does the Devil not have to worry about eating? What does it cost a Devil a month to keep the heat on? How does he get on with Mrs Devil and all the little Devillettes? Does annoying Jean Luc Picard answer any of these questions--and how?
 
  • #66
Khatti said:
Sincerity was supposed to make up for a lot in those days.
I noted that it wasn't making up for awkwardness and absurdity. Jonny Quest was much better written.
 
  • #67
Noisy Rhysling said:
I noted that it wasn't making up for awkwardness and absurdity. Jonny Quest was much better written.

...And a lot more fun to watch.
 
  • #68
Khatti said:
...And a lot more fun to watch.
My first serious relationship in high school started when the neighbor girl started coming over to watch Jonny Quest. At least that's what she said...
 
  • #69
Archaea.
 
  • #70
rollete said:
Archaea.
Aliens?
 
  • #71
Yes, aliens.
 
  • #72
rollete said:
Yes, aliens.
I know of the microbes by that name. Am I on the verge of learning something new?
 
  • #73
Maybe, but probably not.
 
  • #74
rollete said:
Maybe, but probably not.
An interesting alien race... Help me out here.
 
  • #75
Two interesting alien species in Vernor Vinge's "A Fire Upon the Deep" are: (1) A "hive mind" creature whose components are dog-like creatures who synchronize their actions through ultrasonic signals. (2) A plant-like creature with electronic devices to give them short-term memory.
 
  • #76
Khatti said:
My theory is that Krypton is, in fact, in a different universe. Possibly a parallel Earth. I think the only way that Superman could have the powers he has is if he came from a universe that reacts exotically with ours. Little Ka'el brought that universe with him in the person of...his person. How else can you explain his ability to survive in the center of a star?

My theory for superman's powers is that our universe is actually an enormous video game, and the kryptonians found a way to hack it.
 
  • #77
Old UK space comic zero-x had an episode with alien tobacco-like plants. Each had an eye. They were seeking to capture humans because that would confer the plants mobility somehow. The most imaginative detail was, the photographic (celluloid?) film on which the astronauts recorded the plants' images would come alive (upon being developed in the spaceship's dark room?) and attack the crew like snakes on a plane. The exact mechanism was not disclosed, so it was like magic. Now I think of it, it may have had to do with the film being made of essentially cotton fiber (nitrated cellulose) and the plants having the gift of telepathy.

Here's an image:
flowereye.JPG
 
Last edited:
  • #78
In "A Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy", one alien was described as a "sentient shade of the color blue".
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: DennisN
  • #79
stevendaryl said:
In "A Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy", one alien was described as a "sentient shade of the color blue".
He also had a very philosophical bowl of petunias.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: DennisN and stevendaryl
  • #80
stevendaryl said:
My theory for superman's powers is that our universe is actually an enormous video game, and the kryptonians found a way to hack it.

Fair enough...got any thoughts on the plus and minuses of building a Dyson Sphere around a blue giant?
 
  • #81
I remember I liked the idea of a sentient planet in the novel Solaris by Stanislaw Lem, because it was a very unusual and eerie idea which I had not encountered before in science fiction. It was a long time ago I read it, though...
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: EnumaElish
  • #82
how about the "Vashta Nerada" or even the "time lords" hmmmm i wonder if their are related to the
asgardians
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: EnumaElish
  • #83
All of Ursula Le Guin's alien races are great because she makes their strange cultures real. If I am required to pick the one I like best, it would be the Hainish because they are anthropologists who recruit other races to do research for them. See
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: EnumaElish
  • #84
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: EnumaElish
  • #85
The Vulcans.

They are enough like humans so that I can see myself as one of them. On the other hand, although they are not perfect, they are intellectually and spiritually superior to humans. Therefore, they are something to strive for.

I think much more advanced beings, such as the Organians, are fascinating. But they are too advanced for me to see myself as one of them at this stage.

My goal now is to eliminate as many undesirable human attributes as possible. This is one reason I am becoming interested in meditation, because it is indispensable for the Vulcan to maintain a logical mind. When a Vulcan stops meditating, he or she opens the door to emotion, which results of course in deviations from logic.

I admit I am still an emotional and impulsive human. But at least I'm trying to improve.

Nothing unreal exists.

Live long and prosper, humans!
 
  • #86
When you're no longer human check in with us.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Helios
  • #87
Noisy Rhysling said:
When you're no longer human check in with us.

I am a transhumanist. I think transhumanists in general see themselves as continuing their development as humans. It's not that we wish to stop being human. We want to become a better human. In fact, one could say we wish to become more fully human, by living up to our potential.

It's not a binary condition, in the sense of either being human or not being human. I think we are on the continuum of progress, somewhere between the first beings we would call human, and what we can become in the distant future. Perhaps at some stage we will cease to call ourselves humans, but personally I like the idea of tracing myself back to my earliest civilized ancestors. They were human, but not as far along on the continuum of progress as we are.
 
  • #88
A better human wouldn't be human.
 
  • #89
One cannot become Vulcan by getting more like them. They would never consider you as one of them. That's okay, because they are not better than humans intellectually or spiritually. "Better" is so value laden a term right off the bat that we'd go nowhere with it. So, logically (ahem) your goal must at best be one of sideways movement. I guess one can define transhumanism that way, which is no plume off my back. Also, meditation does not lead to logic, or eliminate or control emotion. Not in my experience. Best wishes, and thanks for all the plomik.
 
Last edited:
  • #90
Yggdrasil tree ships