What does exactly constitute plagiarism?

  • Thread starter chhitiz
  • Start date
In summary: I believe. I don't know if there's any international copyrights available (you should check first), but I think you can file for a patent that covers some countries, but not all.
  • #1
chhitiz
221
0
just what i meant by the question. for example if a bloke wrote a paper on an innovative way to use web technology and another bloke used that paper to sell a product, does it amount to plagiarism or does the new method have to be patented first?
im not sure this should be posted in general discussion, but anyways.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
You're talking about two separate issues. Plagiarism is specific to copyright, typically the written word, and is not related to patent. If someone wrote a paper on a new technology the paper itself is copyright protected. The idea in the paper would have to be patented which is a separate process and legal issue.

If you intend to sell a product based on the idea in the paper you need to check patents. Most likely it will be patented and if you are producing the product, not purchasing it from a distributor, you will have to ask permission from the holder of the patent rights to do so, which will most likely cost you if they even allow it.

As far as the paper is concerned you can quote short sections of it with citation in your brochure along with your sales pitch (do not solely reprint sections of the paper) and urge interested customers to find and read the paper for themselves if they wish more information. You could probably get away with printing out the paper and having it available to show customers but distributing (handing out/mailing/ect) copies of the paper without permission could get you in some trouble. If you intend to produce and distribute copies of the paper you can just ask permission from the author. In this case, as opposed to the patent case, you are more likely to get permission for free but I am not really familiar with how authors of research papers react to such requests.
 
  • #3
TheStatutoryApe said:
If you intend to sell a product based on the idea in the paper you need to check patents. Most likely it will be patented and if you are producing the product, not purchasing it from a distributor, you will have to ask permission from the holder of the patent rights to do so, which will most likely cost you if they even allow it.

yes, but what if the idea is not patented?
would that be like a loophole or something?
 
  • #4
chhitiz said:
yes, but what if the idea is not patented?
would that be like a loophole or something?

In the US, I am unsure about other countries, technically the idea still belongs to its progenitor. You may apply for a patent yourself and if the person who came up with the idea does not challenge it then you are fine. If you use the idea without patenting it it is possible that someone else may patent the idea and then you will have to deal with them. If you have been using the unpatented idea but are not the person who came up with it before it was patented by someone else you may have a case for rights to use it (I am unsure about more complex issues) but I think that like the creator you will be required to apply for patent in order to protect that right. I believe it is also legally your duty to check on any patent claims for an idea before you attempt to produce the idea yourself. If you proceed on the basis that you only think that no one else has a patent you will likely lose any case brought against you.
 
  • #5
chhitiz said:
yes, but what if the idea is not patented?
would that be like a loophole or something?

An 'idea' cannot be patented. The product of an idea can be. If the product of the original idea from the original paper is over a year old and the originator of the product from the original paper hasn't filed for a patent (if there is a product described), then it is of the public domain. Also, if you make (or have made) an improvement to the original product, that improvement can be patented.

Anything that's of a written nature falls under the copyright laws of what ever country you are living if you publish it only in that country I believe. I don't know if there's any international copyrights available (you should check first), but I think you can file for a patent that covers some countries, but not all.
 

1. What is considered plagiarism?

Plagiarism is the act of using someone else's ideas, words, or work without giving proper credit or acknowledgement. This includes copying and pasting, paraphrasing without citation, and self-plagiarism.

2. Is plagiarism only related to written work?

No, plagiarism can occur in any form of media, including written work, artwork, music, videos, and more. It is important to give credit to the original creator in all forms of media.

3. What are the consequences of plagiarism?

The consequences of plagiarism can vary depending on the severity and context of the act. In academic settings, it can result in failing grades, suspension, or expulsion. In professional settings, it can damage one's reputation and lead to legal action.

4. How can I avoid plagiarism?

To avoid plagiarism, it is important to always give credit to the original source by properly citing and referencing. Additionally, one can use plagiarism detection software and be mindful of not only copying and pasting, but also paraphrasing without proper citation.

5. Can unintentional plagiarism still occur?

Yes, unintentional plagiarism can occur when one is not aware that they are using someone else's work without proper credit. This can happen due to lack of knowledge of citation rules or carelessness. It is important to always double check and properly cite all sources to avoid unintentional plagiarism.

Similar threads

  • STEM Educators and Teaching
Replies
33
Views
3K
Replies
9
Views
872
Replies
5
Views
946
Replies
1
Views
625
  • General Discussion
Replies
12
Views
1K
  • General Discussion
Replies
4
Views
584
  • Special and General Relativity
Replies
7
Views
1K
  • General Discussion
3
Replies
70
Views
12K
  • Biology and Medical
Replies
4
Views
4K
Replies
14
Views
822
Back
Top