What might happen if an object struck and replaced Luna

  • Thread starter highjustice
  • Start date
In summary, the conversation discusses the possibility of a cataclysmic event where an object strikes the moon, causing its destruction and replacement by a new object with a crystalline core and metallic elements. The end result would be a drastically different Earth with new landmass configurations and a stable new moon. The timeframe for these changes is flexible, but ideally it would be a few thousand years for the Earth to recover and for human life to continue in a recognizable form. The conversation also touches on the potential effects of this event, such as global temperature changes and the possibility of a second event where a chunk of the new moon breaks off and strikes the Earth. The individual asking the question is seeking insight and scientific expertise to determine the feasibility of this
  • #1
highjustice
1
0
I am hoping this might be the right place for this type of question, if not I apologize. I am doing research for a fictional piece and wanted to ask a question on the possible changes in Earth in regards to a meteor impact into our moon.

I am attempting to posit an event where an object strikes the moon in such a way that it causes the destruction of the moon, and the replacement by the new object.

The characteristics of this new object is that it would a crystalline core with a metallic element making up the majority of the object and a surface of rock. A fairly dense object, and the size can be relative to the physics required to make the results I'm looking for theoretically possible. As long as I can reach "theoretically possible", that is all I need.


The end result I'm looking for, and perhaps this is the wrong way to go about it but the other option is restructuring the cataclysmic event in question, is an unrecognizable Earth that consists of different landmass configuration, warmer climate, intense storms over the oceans at the equator, but little change to humans in an evolutionary sense, which may effect the hypothetical amount of time it takes for the Earth to recover to a livable surface state. Most importantly a livable planet with a stable, new moon in place of the old one. Preferably at a lower orbit but leaving human life in a recognizable and largely familiar form as possible.

The amount of time between the event and the present day of the book is irrelevant except in relation to the other pieces (such as humans being much the same in form as today, the amount of time it takes for the change in landmasses, etc). While I understand normal tectonic movement would take millions upon millions of years, I'm hoping that theoretically given any number of factors from such an event that it is possible to have a completely different configuration of landmasses. (change in ocean levels, massive earthquakes, or even chunks of the moon taking up space in the oceans would all be fine)

As if that wasn't convoluted enough I am furthermore looking for a 2nd event that consists of a chunk of this new moon breaking off due to an eruption on the moon and striking the planet, causing enough damage to level mountains (at about 5,000 mi from impact, and they are already nearly falling into the ocean as is, beyond that effects are irrelevant) but hopefully for near full recovery after a couple thousand years max.

This is my first trial run of asking these insane questions, and I know they may sound completely stupid as I have very little background in physics to back up my imagination, which is technically why I'm here. I hate to just arbitrarily say "such and such" happens if it is so outside anything even theoretically possible as to be ridiculous.

If anyone can provide any insight, even if it is to just help me get to a point where I can ask the right questions in the right manner or get me closer to a theoretical positive, I appreciate it.

Oh and I had a hard time even deciding the best place to ask this type of question. It may take multiple scientific professions to start to come up with a full picture of what is theoretically possible, but I figured physics is the best start.

Regards
 
Astronomy news on Phys.org
  • #2
How about this. A large object with a significant fraction of the Moons mass strikes it from a direction against the Moons orbital motion, thereby slowing it down and causing it to fall to a lower orbit. This process rains material down on the Earth and changes the landscape of the moon significantly. The impacts from moon debris cause a global temperature drop due to dust in the atmosphere, causing an ice age that reduces global ocean levels. Over a few thousand years the landscape changes significantly due to the advancing and receding ice, along with natural forces. Humanity survives this barely, and is rebuilding.

I think an impact large enough to level a mountain from 5,000 miles away is a BIT too large. Instead you could have the pieces land on certain areas and level that local area.

Also, I don't know what the tidal effects would be like if the Moon fell to a lower orbit, but I assume this would have some kind of effect. Perhaps more volcanoes erupt on Earth?
 

1. What would happen to the Earth's tides if Luna was struck and replaced?

If Luna was struck and replaced by another object, the Earth's tides would be significantly affected. The gravitational pull of the new object would cause changes in the height and strength of the tides, potentially leading to more extreme high and low tides. It could also disrupt the delicate balance of the ocean's ecosystems.

2. Would there be any changes to the Earth's orbit if Luna was replaced?

Yes, there would be significant changes to the Earth's orbit if Luna was replaced. The gravitational pull of the new object would impact the Earth's motion around the sun, potentially altering its distance and speed. This could have major implications for our planet's climate and weather patterns.

3. How would the replacement of Luna affect the Earth's axial tilt?

The axial tilt, or the angle at which the Earth's axis is tilted, would likely be impacted by the replacement of Luna. This could lead to changes in the Earth's seasons and climate, potentially causing drastic shifts in temperature and weather patterns.

4. Could the replacement of Luna cause any geological changes on Earth?

Yes, the replacement of Luna could potentially cause significant geological changes on Earth. The gravitational pull of the new object and its impact on the Earth's tectonic plates could lead to earthquakes, volcanic eruptions, and other seismic activities. It could also alter the Earth's magnetic field.

5. How would the replacement of Luna affect life on Earth?

The replacement of Luna could have a profound impact on life on Earth. The changes in tides, orbit, axial tilt, and geological activity could disrupt ecosystems and potentially cause mass extinctions. It could also impact human life in terms of climate, weather, and access to resources.

Similar threads

Replies
16
Views
2K
  • Astronomy and Astrophysics
Replies
4
Views
188
  • Astronomy and Astrophysics
Replies
10
Views
2K
  • Astronomy and Astrophysics
Replies
2
Views
1K
  • Astronomy and Astrophysics
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • Astronomy and Astrophysics
Replies
2
Views
914
  • Astronomy and Astrophysics
Replies
12
Views
1K
  • Astronomy and Astrophysics
Replies
9
Views
3K
Replies
42
Views
2K
  • Astronomy and Astrophysics
Replies
21
Views
2K
Back
Top